Difference between revisions of "UDWiki:Administration/Arbitration"

From The Urban Dead Wiki

Jump to: navigation, search
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Shortcut|[[A/A]]}}
+
<big><big>'''Cornholioo hails the death of the 100th survivor killed by Wotan's Templar.'''</big></big>
{{Moderationnav}}
+
{| align="right"
+
|__TOC__
+
|}
+
{{:UDWiki:Administration/Arbitration/Intro}}
+
  
=Arbitration Cases Currently Under Consideration=
 
  
{{ArbitrationNotice}}
+
<big><big><big>'''Heil Hitler!'''</big></big></big>
<!--
+
  
If there is no arbitration cases under consideration, please add the following text to this header
 
''There are currently no cases under consideration''
 
<!-- DO NOT EDIT ABOVE THIS LINE -->
 
  
  
=Arbitration Cases in Progress=
 
<!--
 
  
If there is no arbitration cases under consideration, please add the following text to this header
 
''There are currently no cases under consideration''
 
''There are currently no recently concluded cases, see the [[:Category:Arbitration Cases|archives]] for older cases''
 
<!-- DO NOT EDIT ABOVE THIS LINE -->
 
  
==[[User:Spiderzed]] and [[Big Coffin Hunters]] vs [[User:tyx94]] and [[User:Yonnua Koponen]] vs [[Dulston Alliance]] and [[Burchell Arms Regulars]]==
 
This case is being brought over [[Template:Dulston Groups]]. Tyx94 [http://wiki.urbandead.com/index.php?title=Template%3ADulston_Groups&diff=1847417&oldid=1844785 has] [http://wiki.urbandead.com/index.php?title=Template:Dulston_Groups&diff=next&oldid=1847549 repeatedly] changed the position of the survivor group [[Big Coffin Hunters]] to Hostile Groups (or respectively Zombie Groups).
 
  
[[User_talk:Tyx94#You_are_not_a_member_of_BCH|Requests on Tyx94's talk page]] by two different users to stop those unqualified edits have been voiced, but have been met with announcements to continue the edit warring. As BCH see no other way left to resolve this matter, we've decided to take it to arbitration.
 
  
I, [[User:Spiderzed|Spiderzed]], have been appointed as representative of BCH.
 
  
As for arbitrators, we'd accept the following as fair and unbiased third-parties:
+
List of names:
  
*[[User:Ashley Valentine]]
+
tim f
*[[User:DeWolf]]
+
*[[User:Franz Molotov]]
+
*[[User:Headless gunner]]
+
*[[User:Karloth vois]]
+
*[[User:Mr Watt]]
+
*[[User:Rapture]]
+
*[[User:Skoll]]
+
*[[User:The Colonel]]
+
*[[User:Zombiegeorge]]
+
  
--{{User:Spiderzed/Sandbox/Sig}} 16:13, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
MooZonk
:Bullshit, all biased. Add me to Tyx94's side of the argument. I've had enough of you guys fucking with the group listing too, and I haven't had a good raeg off yet this month.--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 16:16, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::I expected the other party to try to disrupt the process by refusing all arbitrators out of hand. So I prepared a second set of less unbiased, but still acceptable arbitrators along with reasons why they can be trusted:
+
::*[[User:AnimeSucks]] - Resens admin and former bounty hunter in the DA area
+
::*[[User:DT]] - PKA admin
+
::*[[User:Lois Millard]] - RG moderator
+
::*[[User:Maverick Farrant]] - leader of an ally group of Dulston Alliance
+
::*[[User:Misanthropy]] - wiki sysop
+
::*[[User:Sexualharrison]] - completely uninvolved, but still wiki-savvy
+
::*[[User:Sherry Stringfield]] - strictly pro-survivor
+
::As for adding yourself, I'd be fine. Would Tyx be it too? --{{User:Spiderzed/Sandbox/Sig}} 16:22, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
  
As I said on Tyx's page I'd rather see this go through policy. Basically you should determine through policy whether or not suburb group lists are confined to being NPOV (which I think they should) before determine whether groups are survivor/pk/zed through arbitration. --[[Image:Umbrella-White.png|12px]][[User:MisterGame|<span style= "color: maroon; background-color: white">'''''Thadeous Oakley''''']][[Image:Umbrella-White.png|12px]]</span> [[User_Talk:MisterGame|<span style= "color: black; background-color: white">'''''Talk''''']]</span> 16:24, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
Joseph Pople
:I agree with Thadeous. While we will need to arbitrate it, let's wait until after a policy is established. Yon, I'm going to need your wiki knowledge, so any help is appreciated. And I much prefer the second list of arbitrators.--[[User:Tyx94|tyx94]] 16:26, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::Why don't you try suggesting people who are actually on the list of arbitrators? By which I mean that DT, Lois, Anime, Sexual, Sherry and Misanthropy are grossly inappropriate, and I wouldn't want anybody associated with either group arbitrating.--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 17:50, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::Both Maverick and Misanthropy ''are'' on the list of arbitrators. The others might not be, but that has never been a hindrance. --{{User:Spiderzed/Sandbox/Sig}} 18:22, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:I guess no policy on (N)POVness of suburb pages then? Well have fun with arbitration :) --[[Image:Umbrella-White.png|12px]][[User:MisterGame|<span style= "color: maroon; background-color: white">'''''Thadeous Oakley''''']][[Image:Umbrella-White.png|12px]]</span> [[User_Talk:MisterGame|<span style= "color: black; background-color: white">'''''Talk''''']]</span> 17:54, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::I'd be willing for one, but I can tell you now that it will just be meatpuppeted out.--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 17:56, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
  
Lol, establishing through policy. I offer my hat as an arbie. --{{User:Rosslessness/Sig}} 16:49, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
serrenicus
:I accept you, but I don't know who else will.--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 17:50, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::'''I accept Ross.''' However, we absolutely need to have Tyx on board, as he has been the offending party, and a ruling would be senseless without results affecting him. Either he sticks around for this, or lets Yon act in his absence and accepts the fall-out. --{{User:Spiderzed/Sandbox/Sig}} 18:22, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::Cool. Although you would need to clarify his position slightly. Is he representing soley tyx's interest or is he representing the [[DA]]? --{{User:Rosslessness/Sig}} 19:00, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::::I think Tyx is actually representing [[The Burchell Arms Regulars|BAR]]. Although I don't know if he has a DA alt as well. --{{User:Spiderzed/Sandbox/Sig}} 19:07, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::::Tyx and I should both accept, and I'm not representing the DA, I'm representing the wiki as a game resource.--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 19:36, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::::::Well lets wait for that then. --{{User:Rosslessness/Sig}} 19:44, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::::::I would honestly rather try and make a policy first. Wouldn't it be smarter to establish a precendent to go off of? At any rate, I have no problem with Ross; I'm sure he'd be fine. And I'm acting on my own here, not representing any group at all. Just wanna see this get resolved one way or another.--[[User:Tyx94|tyx94]] 20:14, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::::::::OK. Case postponed, whilst Tyx tries to create a workable policy. --{{User:Rosslessness/Sig}} 20:15, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
  
Hasn't this been resolved before with groups like the [[Philosophe Knights]] and [[TZH]]? Standard practice has always been to let groups list where they feel appropriate, not for outsiders to change it at will. {{User:Misanthropy/Sig}} 19:42, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
thething000
:I thought so too. Thus I expect this case to be very easy and quick. --{{User:Spiderzed/Sandbox/Sig}} 19:44, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:Why even bother with categories then? It sounds like any group can list whatever category they want to be in, and so the groupings have no real, consistent meaning. We might as well just remove the categories and list everyone underneath "Groups."-[[MHS|<span style="color: Black">'''MHS'''</span>]][[User_Talk:MHSstaff|<span style="color: DarkBlue">'''staff'''</span>]] 20:00, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::That's kind of my feeling here. Either we use the categories right, or why use them at all? If they aren't accurate information, we're better off throwing categories out altogether.--[[User:Tyx94|tyx94]] 20:14, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::If I could have a word.  I had a thought on this when I was debating on placing [[Organization XIII]] onto [[Lockettside]]'s Survivor group listing, but because we've been helping zeds more since the ratio have been favoring survivors since Org XIII began, I believed there would be edit warring on Org XIII's placing, despite the fact Org XIII is both Pro-Survivor and Hostile (depending on that one important population ratio), and as such, I've yet to add Org XIII to the group listing.  I tried to bring up [[Template talk:SuburbGroups#Dual Nature|adding Dual Nature]] onto the suburb group templates, although that discussion currently has gotten nowhere, as no one bothered to pay any mind to it. --{{User:Axe Hack/Sig}} 20:52, 10 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::::Was going to bring this up myself. --{{:User:Thanatologist/Sig}} 10:54, 14 February 2011 (UTC)
+
Hmmm... nothing for over a week. Withdraw? --{{:User:Thanatologist/Sig}} 14:35, 23 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:The policy discussion has still two days left before being cycled, while the template talk page has no closing date. Still, this looks like one of the many arbies that fade away with a whimper. --{{User:Spiderzed/Sandbox/Sig}} 15:52, 23 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::The template talk has two closing dates: Feb. 28th for nominations, and March 15 for voting. -[[MHS|<span style="color: Black">'''MHS'''</span>]][[User_Talk:MHSstaff|<span style="color: DarkBlue">'''staff'''</span>]] 17:43, 23 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::I refuse to rescind this claim. Either it's solved through PD or the template talk, or I'm having your group forcibly moved to the correct section through arbies.--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 16:07, 23 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::Forcibly moved? --{{User:Rosslessness/Sig}} 16:47, 23 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::::I'm assuming an impartial arbitrator will force them to move it to the correct section.--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 18:13, 23 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::::Yeah, we don't force, we rule. Failure to follow the ruling results in a double escalation. --{{User:Rosslessness/Sig}} 18:16, 23 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::::::Ergh, it's effective forcing. And since it's a community page, an arbitrator can put it in a specific way and tell involved parties not to change it, so technically they can't be forced to do it, but it can be forced to happen by an arbitrator.--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 18:44, 23 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::::::But surely you'd want a precedent, so future issues of editing the page could be handled quickly? You want something that allows you to modify the page regardless of who changes it? --{{User:Rosslessness/Sig}} 18:46, 23 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::::::::Yep, which is why I'd prefer to solve this through the template talk or PD route, but if those policies fail or whatnot, I think it's best that this case stays open so that I don't have to remake it later.--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 18:58, 23 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::::::::As for escalations and enforcement, I'd like to point out in advance that Yon and tyx refused to represent the DA or BAR. As that leaves an easy loophole to circumvent any ruling by employing meatpuppets for editing the template, I'd like either the arbitrator taking this into consideration in the final ruling. Or to allow me to drop BCH's participation, to allow all parties to get out on equal footing. --{{User:Spiderzed/Sandbox/Sig}} 19:20, 23 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::::::::::Sorry, when did we ''refuse to represent the DA and BAR''. If you want to bullshit people so that they agree with you, at least don't do it when it's visible that you're lying from the page. I'm doing this in the best interest of the suburb as an information source, but if you want, I'll happily say I'm a representative of Dead vs Blue, just so that you don't have to bullshit.--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 00:07, 24 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::::::::::I think he may have been somehow led to believe you weren't representing DA when you said "I'm not representing the DA". I have no idea how though. {{User:Misanthropy/Sig}} 00:20, 24 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::::::::::::No, ebcause he said that we're "refusing" to represent our groups. There's a massive gulf of difference.--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 00:42, 24 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::::::::::::If you're not refusing then why not do it in the first place? You deliberately stated who you were attempting to represent almost from the outset; firmly deciding one thing usually means rejecting the notion of anything mutually exclusive with it. Are you or are you not in this arby as a representative of DA or as an individual, or what? Pick something and stick with it so the thing can go as smoothly as possible. {{User:Misanthropy/Sig}} 00:46, 24 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::::::::::::::I'm in this as an individual, but I'm willing to extend it to my group if spiderzed wants. Now stop trolling and GTFO unless you have something actually related to the case to say.--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 00:48, 24 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::::::::::::::I'm hardly trolling, you idiot. A point was raised, you got unnecessarily hostile, and I asked directly how your involvement in the case should be treated so everyone knew clearly. And I'm the troll? I've already stated I want to be involved in this due to its likely effect on PK, so I ''am'' contributing usefully, ''unlike some''. Now if you've nothing more civil or constructive to add, keep quiet until Tyx indicates how he wishes to proceed and this thing actually moves onwards. {{User:Misanthropy/Sig}} 00:51, 24 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::::::::::Both Tyx and Yon ''do'' have a vested, group-related interest into re-classifying BCH, as indicated by the multi-pages thread about BCH on the Dulston Alliance forums, and threats of war by BAR against BCH that were issued at the same time as this case was brought up. It is blatantly obvious to any neutral reader that this just serves to open another front-line in this "war", and is also a bad faith attempt of deception, in order to hedge their bets in case that the arbies case turns out against them by still allowing fellow group members and meat puppets to edit the suburb template at will. I thus refuse to recognize either as representative of "the wiki as an information source", but would rather accept [[User:Misanthropy]] as representative of this party (who isn't involved in either side of this conflict and thus a better representative than any other currently involved party including me). --{{User:Spiderzed/Sandbox/Sig}} 04:45, 24 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::::::::::::Except that a similar argument could be made to where any member of any PKing group, any member of any GKing group, any member of any ZKing group, or really, any member of any group that is not crystal clear, black-and-white, "Zombie," "Survivor," or "Hostile" would also have a "vested" interest in this. Some of them,(Mis) have already posted on the talk page that they would support your POV to protect their "vested" interests. If you were to lose this case, what's to stop you from using your PK connections to have them edit the template at will?
+
  
::::::::::::Yeah. This kinda cuts both ways. My point is if you are going to ask Ross to keep in mind "meat-puppet" voting from vested parties, including ones not even listed on that template page, well, as a neutral reader, I think there are two sides to that coin, and you should probably ask Ross to consider both sources if this ruling is to actually be useful. You know. To avoid any bad faith attempts at deception.-[[MHS|<span style="color: Black">'''MHS'''</span>]][[User_Talk:MHSstaff|<span style="color: DarkBlue">'''staff'''</span>]] 05:40, 24 February 2011 (UTC)
+
sparky the fireman
  
::::::::::::Can you stop trying to get your friends involved as neutral parties please?--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 12:09, 24 February 2011 (UTC)
+
Geckoman
:::::::::::::I'm tired of playing games of semantics. As the aggrieved party, I use my right of accusation to ''additionally'' seek justice against BAR and DA. For now, I'll list them as a third party (as Yon still insists on representing "best interest of the suburb as an information source", while Tyx hasn't yet answered to potentially change his stance as "acting on my own here"). It's up to them to either get a representative here, to appoint Yon/Tyx for that purpose, or to get convicted in absence. --{{User:Spiderzed/Sandbox/Sig}} 13:40, 25 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::::::::::::::As I said; I'm more than happy to represent Dead vs Blue.--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 15:21, 25 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:::::::::::::::I asked for the entire Dulston Alliance, rather than just for Dead vs Blue. Else, that would be as useful as getting a dedicated MFD representative in a case that concerns the entire DEM. --{{User:Spiderzed/Sandbox/Sig}} 15:31, 25 February 2011 (UTC)
+
::::::::::::::::Sorry, but since the dulston alliance is merely an organisation consisting of multiple member groups, if you want a rep, you'll have to settle for one from each member group. I could probbly get them if you want, but some of the groups don't access the wiki v. often. Alright?--{{User:Yonnua Koponen/signature‎}} 00:56, 26 February 2011 (UTC)
+
:remind me not to post a comment and then disappear for a day... I remembered yesterday about the waiting-for-the-policy thing, but couldn't get on yesterday. Now all this greets me when I come back to check... --{{:User:Thanatologist/Sig}} 03:18, 25 February 2011 (UTC)
+
  
Anyway, thanks for all this, its really useful. As noted elsewhere a suburb template discussion is under way and until thats completed this is going nowhere. --{{User:Rosslessness/Sig}} 15:20, 25 February 2011 (UTC)
+
Deathfour
  
=Recently Concluded cases=
+
Zaarik
  
Please see [[:Category:Arbitration Cases]] for older arbitration cases.
+
humphreybot
  
=Archives=
+
Geckoman
  
 +
Rafael Chanan
  
*[[:Category:Arbitration Cases|List of Arbitration Cases]]
+
zombiebossmonster
 +
 
 +
Lou C Fur
 +
 
 +
Famus 101
 +
 
 +
Lucio Chagrini
 +
 
 +
Geckoman
 +
 
 +
Dave Of The Damned
 +
 
 +
DrEvilsberg
 +
 
 +
dunneo
 +
 
 +
Elliott86
 +
 
 +
Garydd Paul
 +
 
 +
drummerboy0
 +
 
 +
planb112
 +
 
 +
Matterfoot
 +
 
 +
Dr Zomboso
 +
 
 +
evilthing
 +
 
 +
Gunsahoy
 +
 
 +
CooperCatz
 +
 
 +
Seth Hawthorne
 +
 
 +
Mexican Zed
 +
 
 +
Dr Adolf Strughold
 +
 
 +
Defender Of Weak
 +
 
 +
phoenixlink2
 +
 
 +
Alfred Skogul
 +
 
 +
pele branco de SP
 +
 
 +
Seth Hawthorne
 +
 
 +
Captain Lavender
 +
 
 +
InvincibleZombie
 +
 
 +
Inlain
 +
 
 +
Tim Braums
 +
 
 +
suvivingpoop
 +
 
 +
iamtehreviver
 +
 
 +
Dr Manson
 +
 
 +
docthehealer
 +
 
 +
Sirraleigh
 +
 
 +
Ceridwen Aurora
 +
 
 +
Steve the Mime
 +
 
 +
Jane Blackman
 +
 
 +
Johnny Darque
 +
 
 +
Space Cowbot
 +
 
 +
Paradoxin
 +
 
 +
InvincibleZombie
 +
 
 +
Jan Marius
 +
 
 +
labfrisco
 +
 
 +
Gehennanow
 +
 
 +
Haargroth
 +
 
 +
William Nichols
 +
 
 +
Dr Zedski
 +
 
 +
Polly Ambrose
 +
 
 +
Dusty Toomes
 +
 
 +
baudome
 +
 
 +
Haloclimb
 +
 
 +
LoliFanFan
 +
 
 +
Arieg
 +
 
 +
Nick Eriksson
 +
 
 +
Elizabeth Wine
 +
 
 +
Zerohelp9
 +
 
 +
ArgRIB
 +
 
 +
Pirim
 +
 
 +
Lucio Chagrini
 +
 
 +
Monty Eelems
 +
 
 +
Li2
 +
 
 +
Soneb Bones
 +
 
 +
Ballz Mohammed
 +
 
 +
Burkeston
 +
 
 +
private kit
 +
 
 +
donquixoto
 +
 
 +
LordEngelbert
 +
 
 +
Laffayette
 +
 
 +
susan highton
 +
 
 +
DudeinaHat
 +
 
 +
UrbanHealer
 +
 
 +
Lt Mike Avery
 +
 
 +
SleepusAnimus
 +
 
 +
Coelo's Revenge
 +
 
 +
Lyle Riveras
 +
 
 +
BTDPIMP
 +
 
 +
killr23578
 +
 
 +
Deadushka
 +
 
 +
Venomclay
 +
 
 +
Young Wanderer
 +
 
 +
April O'Neal
 +
 
 +
Neuromancer7
 +
 
 +
ElkesiNazashca
 +
 
 +
Triple Lanor
 +
 
 +
Ty Milburn
 +
 
 +
Mobin
 +
 
 +
MasterZombo
 +
 
 +
Mad'Mardigan

Revision as of 14:38, 27 February 2011

Cornholioo hails the death of the 100th survivor killed by Wotan's Templar.


Heil Hitler!





List of names:

tim f

MooZonk

Joseph Pople

serrenicus

thething000

sparky the fireman

Geckoman

Deathfour

Zaarik

humphreybot

Geckoman

Rafael Chanan

zombiebossmonster

Lou C Fur

Famus 101

Lucio Chagrini

Geckoman

Dave Of The Damned

DrEvilsberg

dunneo

Elliott86

Garydd Paul

drummerboy0

planb112

Matterfoot

Dr Zomboso

evilthing

Gunsahoy

CooperCatz

Seth Hawthorne

Mexican Zed

Dr Adolf Strughold

Defender Of Weak

phoenixlink2

Alfred Skogul

pele branco de SP

Seth Hawthorne

Captain Lavender

InvincibleZombie

Inlain

Tim Braums

suvivingpoop

iamtehreviver

Dr Manson

docthehealer

Sirraleigh

Ceridwen Aurora

Steve the Mime

Jane Blackman

Johnny Darque

Space Cowbot

Paradoxin

InvincibleZombie

Jan Marius

labfrisco

Gehennanow

Haargroth

William Nichols

Dr Zedski

Polly Ambrose

Dusty Toomes

baudome

Haloclimb

LoliFanFan

Arieg

Nick Eriksson

Elizabeth Wine

Zerohelp9

ArgRIB

Pirim

Lucio Chagrini

Monty Eelems

Li2

Soneb Bones

Ballz Mohammed

Burkeston

private kit

donquixoto

LordEngelbert

Laffayette

susan highton

DudeinaHat

UrbanHealer

Lt Mike Avery

SleepusAnimus

Coelo's Revenge

Lyle Riveras

BTDPIMP

killr23578

Deadushka

Venomclay

Young Wanderer

April O'Neal

Neuromancer7

ElkesiNazashca

Triple Lanor

Ty Milburn

Mobin

MasterZombo

Mad'Mardigan

Personal tools
advertisements