Talk:Scurvy Scroungers: Difference between revisions

From The Urban Dead Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
 
(55 intermediate revisions by 19 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
== Do you zerg? ==
==Spying on the Old Arkham Reclamation Effort in 2021==
This post is to address the above question. I suspect the answer is "yes", but I'd like to present my case here and give you a chance to defend yourself.
Zarak Goldleaf, leader of the Scurvy Scroungers, was caught spying on the Old Arkham Reclamation Effort Discord. He used a false backstory, pretending to be a local survivor called TheAstronomer, and watched our operations to get a tactical advantage. We discovered this when he asked for aid in one of the public channels of the Ridleybank Resistance Front's Discord. The RRF would later kick him from the server, but not before we were able to screenshot proof of the same account between both servers.
=== Scurvy Scoungers named "zerg" ===
The following accounts were all created on 2009-01-03.
*HandyManZerg http://www.urbandead.com/profile.cgi?id=1441846
*PostManZerg http://www.urbandead.com/profile.cgi?id=1441754
*MilkManZerg http://www.urbandead.com/profile.cgi?id=1441850
*GenZerg http://www.urbandead.com/profile.cgi?id=1441751


Furthermore, you've listed CapZerg as an important member of the Scurvy Scroungers.  If so, is he also responsible for the following accounts or are they separate players?
Following this we moved everyone besides "TheAstronomer" to a secret channel, providing bogus information to the main channel and watching to see if he would act on it. Zarak's forces responded within hours, preempting our false targets. When we pretended to bemoan this in chat, "TheAstronomer" would within minutes provide an innocuous explanation for the Scroungers getting the drop on us.
*SergZerg http://www.urbandead.com/profile.cgi?id=1428577
*CapZerg http://www.urbandead.com/profile.cgi?id=1401005
*LtZerg http://www.urbandead.com/profile.cgi?id=1402126
*CorpZerg http://urbandead.com/profile.cgi?id=1428571


There are other scroungers with the last name "zerg" which I have not listed.  I understand that some groups like to choose similar naming conventions to show unity but perhaps you can see why this draws suspicion, particularly with the accounts created on 2009-01-03.
When I confronted him in a private message over Discord, he admitted to the spying and claimed it was "part of the game." Moreover, he made several statements that would seem to corroborate the zerging charges his group has fielded for years (see: the Scurvy Scroungers/Talk Archive below). Among these suspicious statements are bargaining to only skirmish with his "core" group of players if we consent to his territorial terms, asserting that he would go so far as to say his group has "more than 8" people playing despite it having 22 active members, and stating that he would leave TheAstronomer at a location for us to communicate with if we wish (the bizarre implication being, if he isn't zerging, that he would not play within ten spaces of this character as he awaited us to contact him).


=== Confusion among the ranks? ===
Included in this imgur album are screen shots of his spying account, our conversation, and screenshots of a group of new characters (newarkhamhorde1, newarkhamhorde2, newarkhamhorde3, newarkhamhorde4, and newarkhamhorde5) created in the midst of these events.
On your newly created wiki page you've listed Maron Deldibon as an important member of the Scurvy Scroungers.  I have witnessed Maron attacking in turn, within a minute of a Scrounger attack so I believe this claim to be true.  However Maron's group affiliation is actually Urban Paladin, not Scurvy Scrounger.  I can understand the confusion, if you are managing multiple accounts.


Response: The confusion was simply a matter of some players not switching their tag. It's that simple.  Maron was the leader of the Urban Paladins who were a survivor group who switched sides after consistently being pked.  Simply forgot to switch his tag. --[[User:Ebineezer Shifton|Ebineezer Shifton]] 17:07, 21 February 2009 (UTC)
https://imgur.com/a/o4Q5vNj


=== Lack of a wiki or forum ===
While it is notoriously difficult to prove zerging, I felt these merely circumstantial details might be important as part of an ongoing record of suspicious behavior. --[[User:AspiR|AspiR]] ([[User talk:AspiR|talk]]) 04:21, 24 January 2021 (UTC)
This wiki page was created today, Jan 27th, 2009.  For quite a long time the Scroungers consisted of 10 players. But within the last few weeks your numbers have shot up to 21.  This seems unusual since  during that time you had no wiki page or forum to recruit with.  Furthermore, Scurvy Scrounger graffiti in New Arkham is non-existant.


My question to you is - '''"How does a zombie group with no means of in-game communication, no wiki presence, no allies, and no advertising go from 10 to 21 members in a matter of weeks?"'''   
***
Lolololololol.  Hilarious analysis.  A ruse that cost about 20 or 30 bodies each day.  Well done.  Of course I admit to spying, there's no game rule about it (sharing information or bypassing in game communication restrictions on the otherhand...) and if your so dense you walk around broadcasting links to your discord that anyone can pop in and scroll back through your chats on than you deserve to be spied on.  Sorry we aren't a bunch of putz's communicating on public channels like you guys.  


My explanation is quite simpleThere is no need for a forum or an in-game recruitment drive if to bolster your numbers you simply create more accounts.
That I don't screenshot all suspicious stuff from survivors in the area, your group included, and post it is more indicative of how little I care about what you guys are up to rather than indicative of survivors being the 'pure' bs you guys always claimSo many alts with similar names always running around the area, camping outside NT's and whacking zeds inside, etc, anyone who can think can piece it together.  If not you specifically then the chum that has shown up to feed off of you is spamming level 1 survivors into the area and has been since October.  Not complaining, just pointing out no ones hands are clean and this isn't a court where you need to prove anything beyond reasonable doubt.  I have never said no one in our group ever zergs, but I've been playing this account for a long timeIf I was multiplying suspiciously I would be gone a long time ago.
This is my argument.  I have been biased in my argument so that it would stand on its ownHowever I will objectively listen to your response and I hope that the zerging, if it exists, is the result of a rogue member and not your policy as a group.


--[[User:Giles Sednik|Giles Sednik]] 00:45, 28 January 2009 (UTC)
I loved your justification as wanting to make this area 'fun' or whatever bs alluded to.  This area is fun.  I love wandering the streets of my pile of rubble.  Its a big game ruin hunting preserve and we are the caretakers.  We love those guys when they come down and give them a good challenge to get some good repairs.  We talked it over and are redirecting to act as game wardens for this preserve.  Any of them want to come down and safari and we will give them a good game.  The rest of you should pack your bags and beat it.


God I love how much forum spying winds you guys up.  Me and the rest of the scroungers literally just got done with a google meet laugh fest at your guys expense.  Thanks for the hilarious finish to the weekend!  --[[User:Zarak Goldleaf|Zarak Goldleaf]] ([[User talk:Zarak Goldleaf|talk]]) 05:11, 25 January 2021 (UTC)


Response:  Indeed the scroungers did not have a wiki until recently because we are a group of IRL friends and until survivor activity steped up did not need to recruit in game.  The 12 or 13 of us were creating a nice niche in NA with occasional raids into other zones and didn't see the need for a wiki. Furthermore, we recruited through out of game methods largely because it is impossible, or nearly so, for zombies to effectively recruit in game.  We had attempted spraypainting when reved a number of times, but that proved to just get covered over almost immediately.  Our surge in membership was a result of adding aditional IRL friends to the game as well as gaining membership from other games some of our members play, such as MUDs.  Additionally some of our members hadn't added the Scrounger's tag due to some internal confusion.  --[[User:Ebineezer Shifton|Ebineezer Shifton]] 17:14, 21 February 2009 (UTC)
==Old Talk==
Older discussions have been sent to the [[Scurvy Scroungers/Talk Archive]].


== Heads up ==
== Status Check ==


Controll = wrong. Control = right. --{{User:Pestolence/Sig}} 01:09, 28 January 2009 (UTC)
Hey guys, are you still active at all in New Arkham?  The Herd is beginning operations there and are doing a role call on possible allies. --{{User:Boneshred_The_Hungry/Signature}} 00:05, 26 March 2013 (UTC)
:Judging by Aichon marking the group as inactive three years ago (as seen above) I don't think they are. It's worth a check though. --[[User:Zam Hangrah|Zam Hangrah]] 11:09, 26 March 2013 (UTC)
We actually are active in the zone.  We had been inactive for a couple of years, but returned over a year ago, and have actually been maintaining more of a presence on the forums.  We would be delighted to have some allies in the zone for a change and look forward to a cooperative effort.  You can continue to contact me here, or on my user page, or pop into the Mitchener building and visit me there. --[[User:Zarak Goldleaf|Zarak Goldleaf]] 06:24, 28 March 2013 (UTC)
:Fantastic,  glad to hear the Scurvies are still scrounging ^^  I was very excited to see you went through the effort of seeking out and posting on our forums.  I've been in talks with Lebende Tote up in Grigg Heights, and they same amiable to the idea of joining in the carnage down here.  We should consider arranging a meeting between representatives and tacticians from each group, forming a war counsel so to speak.  Working together, there is a good chance that we can do much more than merely drag Nah Argham screaming into the cold grasp of the damned. --{{User:Boneshred_The_Hungry/Signature}} 19:11, 2 April 2013 (BST)
I like this idea.  Moreover, I like the idea of the 3 groups forming up a war council and trying to start up a horde of enough size to begin touring.  We are in construction of forums for our group (we communicate elsewise atm, but our numbers have started to grow) and will let you know when we have them up.  In the mean time, lets coordinate some raids for brainz!  --[[User:Zarak Goldleaf|Zarak Goldleaf]] 05:59, 3 April 2013 (BST)
:Hey Zarak, my apologies for my sudden absence, life decided to be a crazy whore and had me rather occupied.  I'm in discussions with the defacto senior members of the Herd.  I'll give you more details once they've been nailed down. --{{User:Boneshred_The_Hungry/Signature}} 18:22, 15 April 2013 (BST)


You caught a typo.  Thanks?  --[[User:Ebineezer Shifton|Ebineezer Shifton]] 17:09, 21 February 2009 (UTC)
== Moving your archive ==


== I agree with Giles...something's definitely amiss with this crew. ==
Hi Scurvy Scroungers! I wanted to let you know that the [[Scurvy Scroungers/Talk Archive|Scurvy Scroungers Talk Archive]] should be placed on a subpage of [[Scurvy Scroungers]], not a mainspace page unto itself. I can move it to an appropriate location for you; I would suggest [[Scurvy Scroungers/Talk Archive]]. If you would prefer a different subpage name, just let me know and I'll carry it out. Thanks! {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 17:54, 4 April 2013 (BST)


Glad to see it wasn't just me imaginging things and I wouldn't hold my breath awaiting an honest reply from anyone in that crew. {{Unsigned|Stockcs1}}
My bad Bob, didn't even think to check on that. Yeah moving it to the suggested location would be fine by us.  Thanks!  --[[User:Zarak Goldleaf|Zarak Goldleaf]] 05:04, 5 April 2013 (BST)


===Highly organized?===
==Great Suburb Group Massacre 2013==
LOL!, I guess its easy to launched highly organized attacks when they are controlled by only a few people. You went from 10-30 members almost overnight, no longstanding,highly advertised, well known groups have posted those kind of numbers which leaves only a single conclusion. Your group and others who engage in this kind of play are a bane to this game and the principle of fairplay. You destroy the balance that is achieved by the 50 AP limit...blah blah blah, you already know all of this and probably don't care, if you did you wouldn't be doing it in the first place. Disgusting.--[[User:Legion|Legion]] 19:07, 30 January 2009 (UTC)


== The Great Suburb Group Massacre, 2009 ==
I'm a volunteer helping to do some janitorial work on the suburb pages of the wiki. As part of that, we're double-checking in which suburbs each group is active. Currently, you're listed in one or more suburbs, in addition to using a radio frequency. If you would like to continue being listed, then please respond within the next month with the radio frequency you are using and a list of every suburb where you are currently active. If we don't hear back from you or we can't get the information we need, we'll be removing you from the lists, but you're welcome to re-add yourself later. If you have any questions, feel free to visit our informational page. Thanks. {{User:RadicalWhig/sig}} 13:23, 25 October 2013 (BST)
:Because your group hasn't responded within a month, your suburb and radio listings have been removed. Feel free to relist your group.  {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 16:26, 27 November 2013 (UTC)


{{Group Active?}}
== Question ==


Occasionally, general checks are done of group activity. This may seem like a stupid question, but it's for all groups, regardless of size. {{User:The_Rooster/Sig}} 15:03, 13 February 2009 (UTC)
Seems that your group is a little far from home. Why is that? {{User:Stelar/sig}} 06:25, 18 April 2021 (UTC)
 
I'm not sure really.  Our numbers have almost doubled in the last 6 weeks or so (new scroungers joined and old scroungers came back) and I'm not sure where everyone is at the moment.  I only vaguely recognize your name and group but seem to have you flagged as not a dick in my contacts list. Are you wanting a skirmish or a ruin hunt, perhaps a 'mall raid' game?  Come to the Mitchener, kiss my ring, and we can hash out an accord.  --[[User:Zarak Goldleaf|Zarak Goldleaf]] ([[User talk:Zarak Goldleaf|talk]]) 13:26, 18 April 2021 (UTC)
 
:Isn't your group based in New Arkham? Why would they be continually ruining buildings three to four suburbs away? Also I'm intrigued as to how you have me in your contacts list. As far as I know I've never encountered you in game. {{User:Stelar/sig}} 22:03, 22 April 2021 (UTC)
:The gang is all over the place doing whatever it is that they do. I don't keep them on a leash, I just coordinate strategy for them, monitor the wiki, and let them know what the patrols look like in our territory.  Probably they think its hilarious to roam that far or are chasing some dickholes, or harassing Smithwcks, I can't say for certain as I mostly just hang out here in my rubble but if they are bothering you its probably been collateral damage and someone else has their ire.  I have you in my 'not an ass' color code because that's what the gang tells me and I see you post on forums here and there.  --[[User:Zarak Goldleaf|Zarak Goldleaf]] ([[User talk:Zarak Goldleaf|talk]]) 01:05, 26 April 2021 (UTC)

Latest revision as of 01:05, 26 April 2021

Spying on the Old Arkham Reclamation Effort in 2021

Zarak Goldleaf, leader of the Scurvy Scroungers, was caught spying on the Old Arkham Reclamation Effort Discord. He used a false backstory, pretending to be a local survivor called TheAstronomer, and watched our operations to get a tactical advantage. We discovered this when he asked for aid in one of the public channels of the Ridleybank Resistance Front's Discord. The RRF would later kick him from the server, but not before we were able to screenshot proof of the same account between both servers.

Following this we moved everyone besides "TheAstronomer" to a secret channel, providing bogus information to the main channel and watching to see if he would act on it. Zarak's forces responded within hours, preempting our false targets. When we pretended to bemoan this in chat, "TheAstronomer" would within minutes provide an innocuous explanation for the Scroungers getting the drop on us.

When I confronted him in a private message over Discord, he admitted to the spying and claimed it was "part of the game." Moreover, he made several statements that would seem to corroborate the zerging charges his group has fielded for years (see: the Scurvy Scroungers/Talk Archive below). Among these suspicious statements are bargaining to only skirmish with his "core" group of players if we consent to his territorial terms, asserting that he would go so far as to say his group has "more than 8" people playing despite it having 22 active members, and stating that he would leave TheAstronomer at a location for us to communicate with if we wish (the bizarre implication being, if he isn't zerging, that he would not play within ten spaces of this character as he awaited us to contact him).

Included in this imgur album are screen shots of his spying account, our conversation, and screenshots of a group of new characters (newarkhamhorde1, newarkhamhorde2, newarkhamhorde3, newarkhamhorde4, and newarkhamhorde5) created in the midst of these events.

https://imgur.com/a/o4Q5vNj

While it is notoriously difficult to prove zerging, I felt these merely circumstantial details might be important as part of an ongoing record of suspicious behavior. --AspiR (talk) 04:21, 24 January 2021 (UTC)

Lolololololol. Hilarious analysis. A ruse that cost about 20 or 30 bodies each day. Well done. Of course I admit to spying, there's no game rule about it (sharing information or bypassing in game communication restrictions on the otherhand...) and if your so dense you walk around broadcasting links to your discord that anyone can pop in and scroll back through your chats on than you deserve to be spied on. Sorry we aren't a bunch of putz's communicating on public channels like you guys.

That I don't screenshot all suspicious stuff from survivors in the area, your group included, and post it is more indicative of how little I care about what you guys are up to rather than indicative of survivors being the 'pure' bs you guys always claim. So many alts with similar names always running around the area, camping outside NT's and whacking zeds inside, etc, anyone who can think can piece it together. If not you specifically then the chum that has shown up to feed off of you is spamming level 1 survivors into the area and has been since October. Not complaining, just pointing out no ones hands are clean and this isn't a court where you need to prove anything beyond reasonable doubt. I have never said no one in our group ever zergs, but I've been playing this account for a long time. If I was multiplying suspiciously I would be gone a long time ago.

I loved your justification as wanting to make this area 'fun' or whatever bs alluded to. This area is fun. I love wandering the streets of my pile of rubble. Its a big game ruin hunting preserve and we are the caretakers. We love those guys when they come down and give them a good challenge to get some good repairs. We talked it over and are redirecting to act as game wardens for this preserve. Any of them want to come down and safari and we will give them a good game. The rest of you should pack your bags and beat it.

God I love how much forum spying winds you guys up. Me and the rest of the scroungers literally just got done with a google meet laugh fest at your guys expense. Thanks for the hilarious finish to the weekend! --Zarak Goldleaf (talk) 05:11, 25 January 2021 (UTC)

Old Talk

Older discussions have been sent to the Scurvy Scroungers/Talk Archive.

Status Check

Hey guys, are you still active at all in New Arkham? The Herd is beginning operations there and are doing a role call on possible allies. --Boneshred The Hungry 00:05, 26 March 2013 (UTC)

Judging by Aichon marking the group as inactive three years ago (as seen above) I don't think they are. It's worth a check though. --Zam Hangrah 11:09, 26 March 2013 (UTC)

We actually are active in the zone. We had been inactive for a couple of years, but returned over a year ago, and have actually been maintaining more of a presence on the forums. We would be delighted to have some allies in the zone for a change and look forward to a cooperative effort. You can continue to contact me here, or on my user page, or pop into the Mitchener building and visit me there. --Zarak Goldleaf 06:24, 28 March 2013 (UTC)

Fantastic, glad to hear the Scurvies are still scrounging ^^ I was very excited to see you went through the effort of seeking out and posting on our forums. I've been in talks with Lebende Tote up in Grigg Heights, and they same amiable to the idea of joining in the carnage down here. We should consider arranging a meeting between representatives and tacticians from each group, forming a war counsel so to speak. Working together, there is a good chance that we can do much more than merely drag Nah Argham screaming into the cold grasp of the damned. --Boneshred The Hungry 19:11, 2 April 2013 (BST)

I like this idea. Moreover, I like the idea of the 3 groups forming up a war council and trying to start up a horde of enough size to begin touring. We are in construction of forums for our group (we communicate elsewise atm, but our numbers have started to grow) and will let you know when we have them up. In the mean time, lets coordinate some raids for brainz! --Zarak Goldleaf 05:59, 3 April 2013 (BST)

Hey Zarak, my apologies for my sudden absence, life decided to be a crazy whore and had me rather occupied. I'm in discussions with the defacto senior members of the Herd. I'll give you more details once they've been nailed down. --Boneshred The Hungry 18:22, 15 April 2013 (BST)

Moving your archive

Hi Scurvy Scroungers! I wanted to let you know that the Scurvy Scroungers Talk Archive should be placed on a subpage of Scurvy Scroungers, not a mainspace page unto itself. I can move it to an appropriate location for you; I would suggest Scurvy Scroungers/Talk Archive. If you would prefer a different subpage name, just let me know and I'll carry it out. Thanks! Bob Moncrief EBDW! 17:54, 4 April 2013 (BST)

My bad Bob, didn't even think to check on that. Yeah moving it to the suggested location would be fine by us. Thanks! --Zarak Goldleaf 05:04, 5 April 2013 (BST)

Great Suburb Group Massacre 2013

I'm a volunteer helping to do some janitorial work on the suburb pages of the wiki. As part of that, we're double-checking in which suburbs each group is active. Currently, you're listed in one or more suburbs, in addition to using a radio frequency. If you would like to continue being listed, then please respond within the next month with the radio frequency you are using and a list of every suburb where you are currently active. If we don't hear back from you or we can't get the information we need, we'll be removing you from the lists, but you're welcome to re-add yourself later. If you have any questions, feel free to visit our informational page. Thanks. --RWSig1.png RWSig2.pngFoD PK Praise Rando! 13:23, 25 October 2013 (BST)

Because your group hasn't responded within a month, your suburb and radio listings have been removed. Feel free to relist your group. Bob Moncrief EBDW! 16:26, 27 November 2013 (UTC)

Question

Seems that your group is a little far from home. Why is that? stelar Talk|MCM|EBD|Scourge 06:25, 18 April 2021 (UTC)

I'm not sure really. Our numbers have almost doubled in the last 6 weeks or so (new scroungers joined and old scroungers came back) and I'm not sure where everyone is at the moment. I only vaguely recognize your name and group but seem to have you flagged as not a dick in my contacts list. Are you wanting a skirmish or a ruin hunt, perhaps a 'mall raid' game? Come to the Mitchener, kiss my ring, and we can hash out an accord. --Zarak Goldleaf (talk) 13:26, 18 April 2021 (UTC)

Isn't your group based in New Arkham? Why would they be continually ruining buildings three to four suburbs away? Also I'm intrigued as to how you have me in your contacts list. As far as I know I've never encountered you in game. stelar Talk|MCM|EBD|Scourge 22:03, 22 April 2021 (UTC)
The gang is all over the place doing whatever it is that they do. I don't keep them on a leash, I just coordinate strategy for them, monitor the wiki, and let them know what the patrols look like in our territory. Probably they think its hilarious to roam that far or are chasing some dickholes, or harassing Smithwcks, I can't say for certain as I mostly just hang out here in my rubble but if they are bothering you its probably been collateral damage and someone else has their ire. I have you in my 'not an ass' color code because that's what the gang tells me and I see you post on forums here and there. --Zarak Goldleaf (talk) 01:05, 26 April 2021 (UTC)