View source for UDWiki:Open Discussion/Implementation of UDWiki Discord rules

==Background==

This is an unusual Open Discussion seeing as it's a meta-wiki issue, but we've had some problems in the past 24 hours on the Urban Dead Wiki Discord channel.

Drama caused by an UDWiki-permabanned trouble user coming to Discord has caused a problem with what the community expects of a sysop's responsibilities on Discord. Because the user wasn't banned once the conversation went downhill, users engaged in hostile discussion and eventually sabotaged the discord channel with inane discussion and @everyone spam. As it stands, the following discord (lol) caused more ruckus than Corn's initial arrival. If 'chat disruption' was a banworthy offence, many rightfully angry people would be banned right now.

I understand why the community was frustrated, while also understanding why the sysop team didn't feel able to satisfactorily resolve the issue as it unfolded. On one hand, the community expects fair and decent decision to be meted out efficiently. But on the other hand, sysops don't usually make up rules on the fly. They interpret rules that are decided upon by the community.

Well, I think this is a good chance for us all to discuss whether we should make some ground rules for Discord that the sysops feel more comfortable enforcing. They need to be fair, quickly enforceable, and hopefully not require a drastic increase in oversight. I think it needs to reflect the principles of the wiki, ie. no civility policy. But focus more on avoiding derailment of discussion that temporarily ruins the Discord channel for its regular uses.

Things I think we should avoid is a system as onerous on discussion as UDWiki's vandal system. It needs to be something sysops can quickly act on.

For other users of Discord channels with functioning rules systems, please share them. I'm familiar with IRC systems, not so much Discord, as it stands. Any examples are helpful.

And if anyone wants to discuss the actual drama that unfolded in the past two days, please hash it out on the talk page if necessary. Bring it up if relevant here, but let's focus on the rules at hand please. {{User:DanceDanceRevolution/tcs}} 11:02, 16 August 2018 (UTC)

==General Discussion and Thoughts==
Other thoughts I had were- Having model non-sysop users given ops on the channel for coverage might be good. We have an opportunity here to avoid red tape associated with the wiki and do things that work for Discord that don't work on the wiki. I'm cool with keeping this chill and not policy-dictated. {{User:DanceDanceRevolution/tcs}} 11:02, 16 August 2018 (UTC)

The Discord is an entirely separate entity created by Bob and only insofar official as no one has bothered to create any competition (as was the case with the UDWiki IRC for a while when there were 2 competing IRC channels). It would ultimately be up to Bob how to handle and how strictly to moderate it, and to the users to vote with their feet. --'''<span style="font-family:monospace; background-color:#222222">[[User:Spiderzed|<span style="color:Lime"> Spiderzed</span>]][[User talk:Spiderzed|<span style="color:Lime">▋</span>]]</span>''' 12:12, 16 August 2018 (UTC)
: Bob as dictator on the wiki would make it easier to kill whatever needs to die. I say go for it! (It seems pretty easy to ban a user on discord) -- [[User:Jack&#39;s Inflamed Sense Of Rejection|King AudioAttack]] ([[User talk:Jack&#39;s Inflamed Sense Of Rejection|talk]]) 12:45, 16 August 2018 (UTC)
::Having more OPs online would be an excellent idea. The next time the "Totally Not a Nazi Anymore" Permabanned User in question decided to rattle off a laundry list of holocaust denialism, having someone on the spot to take action and forestall another 5 hours of "debate" would probably be helpful. [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 13:27, 16 August 2018 (UTC)
::"sabotaged the discord channel with inane discussion and @everyone spam"... that's a funny way to say "drew attention to the infestation of literal Nazis and Nazi sympathisers in the server." Fuck you, fuck your family, fuck everyone who has ever crossed paths with you, fuck the specific people who assembled the specific machine you are using to type your words, you Nazi apologist piece of shit. [[User:Igotmadenoughtomakeanewaccount|Igotmadenoughtomakeanewaccount]] ([[User talk:Igotmadenoughtomakeanewaccount|talk]])
:::And if you think disrupting chat and no-platforming a fascist is worse than BEING A NAZI, well, fuck you etc. again. You absolutely worthless waste of space. You outhouse breeze. You schmuck. You hangnail. You piece of dog shit on the heel of a $1000 pair of Oxfords. You crisp lodged in a tooth at just the right angle you can't floss it out. You spineless apologist for all things evil in the world. You brainless toady. You chinless halfman who thinks being white makes him superior by right to all humanity. You umbrella with a hole in it. You '''absolute fucker'''. [[User:Igotmadenoughtomakeanewaccount|Igotmadenoughtomakeanewaccount]] ([[User talk:Igotmadenoughtomakeanewaccount|talk]]) 14:08, 16 August 2018 (UTC)
::::Yep, definitely said one was worse than the other. Sigh. {{User:DanceDanceRevolution/tcs}} 22:00, 16 August 2018 (UTC)
Having just come back to the game, just about the first thing I saw when joining that discord server is literal Nazi propaganda. It shouldn't take 48 hours of debate and a signature from Daddy to decide if Holocaust Denialism is bad. It's an absolute embarrassment, and the fact that none of your "sysops" has the guts to make a stand on LITERAL NAZISM is absolutely appalling. Good luck with player retention if this is the first thing that others see when they start getting involved with the game. --Ocular 14:22, 16 August 2018 (UTC)
:Most of os already left due to the amount of toxic nazi bullshit. Hail [[User:Jack&#39;s Inflamed Sense Of Rejection|King AudioAttack]] ([[User talk:Jack&#39;s Inflamed Sense Of Rejection|talk]]) 17:11, 16 August 2018 (UTC)

Hi! Sorry, I was technically out of town and thus only had access via my phone for the last 36 hours. Please see the below, and I'm really sorry to y'all and to anyone else who was driven away by the lack of prompt moderation; it was definitely not my intent, and I apologize. {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 18:19, 16 August 2018 (UTC)

Whether there should be rules and enforcement thereof on the Discord server is a non-discussion. Of ''course'' there should be basic rules of conduct for the goddamned thing. There should also be moderators/admins who actually moderate instead of hiding behind "sysops are not moderators". In fact, if our wiki sysops aren't inclined to also moderate the ''official UDWiki Discord'', then they should not have any rights on the Discord beyond that of normal users. I can see a reason to tag them as "Wiki Sysops" and give them a special colored name, but if they don't want to have any responsibilities on the Discord they don't deserve any privileges either. As for what form the rules should take, apparently following Wheaton's Law (Don't Be A Dick) is too hard for people to understand/too easy for asshats to deliberately misunderstand, so here's a basic fucking template for reasonable rules on any Discord server:
<blockquote>
'''DO'''
# Be respectful to each other - no racism, sexism, etc.
# Post content in the relevant channels.
# Trash talk each other via #ingame within reason.
# Summon a moderator or admin when someone's being an asshat

'''DON'T'''
# Post links to illegal or malicious content - no CP, dox, malware, pirated goods, etc.
# Harass other people, espouse fascism, or do other things which would get you punched IRL.
# Confuse trash talk contained within #ingame for personal attacks
# Be A Dick
</blockquote>

Also, fuck Nazis forever. --{{User:Dragonshardz/dragonshardz}} {{Goonsig|Dragonshardz}} 03:07, 17 August 2018 (UTC)

:One notable thing that distinguishes UDWiki from other communities is '''that there has never been a civility policy''' - [[UDWiki:Administration/Policy_Discussion/Civility|it was attempted and shot down by the very community]]. Sys-ops take a more technical, janitorial role and generally keep their nose out of the interaction between users, and sys-ops explicitely aren't moderators. Users can be impolite, unfriendly jerks as much as they like (as long as they don't break any rules or get bound up by arbitration agreements in the process), and {{WIKILAW}} can only do jack shit about them. --'''<span style="font-family:monospace; background-color:#222222">[[User:Spiderzed|<span style="color:Lime"> Spiderzed</span>]][[User talk:Spiderzed|<span style="color:Lime">▋</span>]]</span>''' 12:37, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
:You're assuming that everyone will act like sensible adults with those rules. This game has been running for so long that those in their teens/early 20s have reached mid-to-late 20s and early 30s at least, and to see the discord turn into the schmozzle it was, was really quite disappointing. Especially since I had specifically stated that I wasn't currently available to do anything. But what I really wanted to say was if we were to choose people to moderate that server, how would we actually do that? What criteria would we use? How would we trust those we gave powers to would actually moderate fairly? {{User:Stelar/sig}} 13:16, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
::Choose active and willing members of the community, if they abuse Bob sanctions them and restores the normal order. It's not a tricky idea. Also the notion that everyone itc has been playing the game for 10 years and is nearing 30 seems...simplistic. [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 14:21, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
::Discord itself has rules on its use. That would be a starting point.--{{User:Gardenator/sig}} 13:33, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
:How would we feel considering '''"DON'T"''' rules 1-4 could have gotten 90% of the Cornholioo protesters banned over the span of the last 48 hours (only counting #1 if we count @everyone spamming as malicious link usage)? {{User:DanceDanceRevolution/tcs}} 13:48, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
::This seems facile - 1. Ridiculous interpretation, that'd at best be #4, 2. ?, 3. At no point was Cornholio ingame trash talking, merely using #ingame to trashtalk rl, 4. Well I guess we're all gone then. But if we had above rules to begin with, and moderation to back them up, the discussion would never have gotten to that point. [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 14:20, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
:::Considering you Globetrotters haven't been exemplary wiki users, I wouldn't trust you to moderate the discord fairly. Also, you guys kept that conversation going when Cornholioo wasn't even there. He merely said a couple of things, and you guys took off running with that whole conversation. So again, how could we choose trustworthy mods? {{User:Stelar/sig}} 14:27, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
::::I don't think any of us requested, nor particularly would -want- the position. I have faith that the leading figures of this community would be able to identify good reliable active people surely. As for the larger discussion pre-Cornholio's return to spew Nazism - I'm happy to acknowledge our role in if if you acknowledge we weren't the only ones keeping it alive, as you apparently seem to think. [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 14:48, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::I read back over the entire thing, and it was you guys that perpetuated the conversation. And then your buddy Cup Runneth Over decided to be a douchebag and @everyone. So yes, it really was you guys that kept that conversation going. {{User:Stelar/sig}} 15:01, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::And you wonder why we might consider you biased. It's a non sequitur anyway for the topic at hand. [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 15:02, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::Biased how exactly? You guys pinged me your concerns, then instead of shutting up about said topic, you kept it running for like 4 or so hours. And <i> I'm</i> the one that is biased?c {{User:Stelar/sig}} 15:44, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::::Yes. --[[User:ShaqFu|ShaqFu]] <span style="font-size:xx-small; letter-spacing: -2px; text-shadow: #cc4444 1px 1px 10px">[[File:555Manbabies.gif|You rated this wiki '1'! Great job, go hog wild!|link=User:ShaqFu]][[User:ShaqFu|<span style="color:#FF0018">&#124;</span>]][[User:Katthew|<span style="color:#33DD33">&#124;</span>]][[User:Ryu|<span style="color:#FF0048">&#124;</span>]][[User:SprCobra|<span style="color:#FF0060">&#124;</span>]][[User:Laughing Man|<span style="color:#FF0078">&#124;</span>]][[User:Revenant|<span style="color:#FF0090">&#124;</span>]][[User:underisk|<span style="color:#FF00A8">&#124;</span>]][[User:I WARNED YOU ABOUT TEMPLATES BRO|<span style="color:#FF00C0">&#124;</span>]][[User:DeRathi|<span style="color:#FF00D8">&#124;</span>]][[User:DerpDerp|<span style="color:#FF00F0">&#124;</span>]][[User:Abd al-Rahim ibn al-Husain al-'Iraqi|<span style="color:#FF00ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Sykic|<span style="color:#E700ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Vaporware|<span style="color:#CF00ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Nubis |<span style="color:#9F00ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Riseabove|<span style="color:#8700ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Teehee McGee |<span style="color:#6F00ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Anothergenericzombie|<span style="color:#5700ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Ryu|<span style="color:#0048ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Mortimer Wiley|<span style="color:#0044DD">&#124;</span>]][[User:Deadone|<span style="color:#3F00ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:woland37|<span style="color:#2700ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Colbear|<span style="color:#0000dd">&#124;</span>]][[User:Oh no!|<span style="color:#27ff00">&#124;</span>]][[User:Bender Bending Rodriguez|<span style="color:#0F00ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Gardenator|<span style="color:#808000">&#124;</span>]][[User:ephphatha |<span style="color:#0000ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:SA|<span style="color:#0018ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Sniper625 |<span style="color:#0030ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Envious |<span style="color:#0060ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:ED Nort |<span style="color:#0078ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:ED Nort |<span style="color:#0078ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Moraldelima |<span style="color:#0090ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:SenorFP |<span style="color:#00A8ff">&#124;</span>]][[User:Dragonshardz |<span style="color:#00C0ff">&#124;</span>]]</span> 15:50, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::::I too remember how we filibustered unilaterally for four hours completely by ourselves. What a crazy night. The bias is clear Slanted Stelar. [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 15:55, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::::Stelar, you are ignoring that we were arguing with 3-4 people who were either defending corns right to be a Nazi or was a holocaust denier/minimizer.  We were not just talking amongst ourselves about the Nazi.
:::::::Also, one of those accounts only popped up during the conversation.  Somebody didn't want to use their main account to argue their pro Nazi stance (I'm assuming it was corn).--{{User:Gardenator/sig}} 18:39, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::::"Just talking amongst ourselves about the Nazi" actually sums up the week spectacularly well. And seriously, don't present that it doesn't. {{User:DanceDanceRevolution/tcs}} 15:51, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::::::The term you are using "ourselves" applies to everyone chatting about nazis during that 8 hours or so.  The holocaust minimizer and the free speech for all (even nazis)ier which was about 4 people vs self righteous goons.  My responses are to counter the apparent attempt to portray the Nazi fun time as a non event and with goons pinging everyone the worst thing to happen.--{{User:Gardenator/sig}} 16:39, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::::::That's fair, though I will once again say (though I may have missed some statements) that I haven't yet seen someone actually say anything close to "goons pinging everyone" was worse than Nazi propaganda. {{User:DanceDanceRevolution/tcs}} 16:54, 18 August 2018 (UTC)

Responses to Dragonshardz and the above:

Technically, it is the '''unofficial''' UDWiki discord server. Kevan doesn't own it, and has never shown up there; I also created it myself, without even running it by the sop team beforehand as far as I can recall.

As I said below, the primary reasons I've given sysops a special color/role are twofold. The first and most important is to identify us — so users with wiki- or game-related questions can ask a sysop specifically, or can private message one of us if they so choose. The second is the '''optional''' moderation, which wouldn't be obligatory even if the discord ''was'' official — since, even on here, '''sysops are not moderators'''. That said, a major mechanism I use to evaluate my own & others' trust in community members is the sysop application process — so if someone ''does'' want to moderate, I strongly encourage you to [[A/PM|apply to become a sysop]]~

In terms of the specific do's and don't's. Now that there is no non-UD-related talk permitted, do #1 & don't #2 shouldn't be a problem except where it falls within do #3. Do #4, the person to summon is me (other sysops may choose to act or not, their choice), although be warned I interpret "asshat" broadly but "bannable asshat" very narrowly, and I also sleep sometimes (shockingly). Don't #1 means you're in violation of Discord's rules, and therefore reportable to Discord for banning from the platform entirely.

I think the pro- and anti-Murderess discussions are a good counterpoint. On the server, they've often been quite nasty, and drag on for hours and hundreds of messages, but they've ''always'' been on-topic to her, her allies' and her opponents' actions in-game, on the wiki, or on other discord servers, and I've never been close to tempted to banning anyone for them (although it would make my reading load a lot lighter). {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 18:23, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
:This response is directed first at stelar, but I'll get to you, Bob, don't worry. First of all, stelar, '''fuck you''' and fuck your refusal to do anything about ''actual goddamned Nazis'' on the Discord. Fuck Aichon too, for that matter. And fuck ''you'', Bob, for giving people power and privileges beyond that of other users on the Discord and not making them responsible for ''using'' those powers at all, much less in a just manner. If sysops are not moderators, why the fuck do they have what amount to moderator powers on the Discord?

:Secondly, the reason to have a list of rules is so that people who break them face the consequences. The point of having ''moderators'', instead of mealy-mouthed sysops who hide behind "we're not moderators!" to avoid taking action to ban Nazis, Nazi sympathizers, and Holocaust deniers, is to ''enforce'' the rules - not only the letter but the spirit! Fuck you, in general, for that.

:Lastly, fuck you for thinking that a group of nerds shouting at Nazis for being Nazis is remotely a bigger problem than there being ''actual fucking Nazis'' on the Discord server. Fuck you, fuck your shit, and the horse you rode in on. Did you really expect people to quietly let Nazis keep Nazi-ing about after you popped up long enough to do fuckall? --{{User:Dragonshardz/dragonshardz}} {{Goonsig|Dragonshardz}} 01:37, 18 August 2018 (UTC)

::Sysops aren't moderators '''on the wiki'''. If you can't handle that, maybe neither the wiki nor the discord is the place for you? There are many communities out there online run in very different ways.
::There were '''no rules to enforce''' until I listed newly-implemented rules (see below) after all this went down. That's my bad, and I've apologized (and apologize again) for it, because I didn't realize the discord would get as much traction as it has.
::Nazis are '''worse''' than people shouting about nazis. Doesn't mean that either of those has a place on the discord server from here on out.
::Also, why does Stelar get so much more hate than I do, from everybody? She did literally nothing more or less than I did (aka being offline at the time, and expressing as much). So ??? I'm truly baffled by this one. {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 04:14, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
:::I'm irritated at stelar (and aichon) having the power to deal with the nazis and refusing to, even when summoned repeatedly. I'm baffled at them having the ''power'' to do so and hiding behind not being moderators ''on the wiki'' to excuse their inaction on Discord. Stelar's getting more people mad at her because while you've admitted to fault, and Aichon's admitted he just doesn't want to, stelar's been bleating out excuses and implying our refusal to stop bothering you lot about the fascists was somehow The Problem. This irritates ''me'', specifically, because she's trying to have it both ways: she ''wants'' the power to moderate behavior on the wiki, but doesn't care enough/is too busy to ''use'' that power.

:::To sum up: If you're going to have rules, they had damn well better be enforced. People who have the ''ability'' to enforce the rules also have the ''responsibility'' to enforce the rules. People who do not have the responsibility to enforce the rules should not have any special abilities beyond those of a normal user. --{{User:Dragonshardz/dragonshardz}} {{Goonsig|Dragonshardz}} 04:24, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
::::Yeah my beef with Stelar is largely the bias shown - in this case putting what feels like the blame for the events entirely on the anti-nazi contingent, a group which she has pre-existing reason to be disposed against. Now that there are no more Nazis, we shouldn't have any further problems about shouting about them which solves that issue. Otherwise I agree with Dragon - empower those who are interested in keeping order, and don't be surprised if people get peeved at those who do have that power but choose not to use it when called upon. [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 04:33, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::Ahhh, to you both, here's where we differ. People who have the ability ''and the role requirement'' to enforce the rules ''then and only then'' have the responsibility. Only I, as owner of the server, have taken that role requirement onto myself; others have the ''role option'' only, and I will vigorously defend Aichon and Stelar to the death for that. ("If you have any power, you are required to use it" violates the basic rules of logic, and also isn't how human society operates.)Also, gonna repeat the point that there ''weren't rules to enforce'' when all of the lack of activities you're mad about occurred — with the exception of Discord's rules, which allow anyone (anyone!) to report violating users to Discord itself. {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 04:37, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::If you want to bring that up, we did report. Someone deleted all the offending posts in the interim, rendering the reports useless because the deletions were done improperly. That those with the power *could* do something but choose not to, well, I guess we philosophically differ on whether or not it's fair to get peeved at said users for inactivity. Sure hope you deputize some people who are interested at some point. (Again, sure not me before Stelar or whoever was making that point earlier brings it up again.) [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 04:41, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::::I was <i>at work</i>. I was on my lunch break when this all was starting, and had to get back to work not long after. I'm not on my phone at work, nor do I have any ability to be on discord on a computer. I literally <i>couldn't</i> do anything at that time. {{User:Stelar/sig}} 04:46, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::::Btw, that person was me — I banned Corn and deleted #off-topic before I realized that. I'd have banned with no message deletion and locked the channel (I think there's a way to do that) until reports were processed if I'd known they were ongoing. (I feel bad, but also literally nobody private messaged me letting me know as much, so not sure how sorry I can be on this one.) {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 04:49, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::::How convenient. Either you screwed it up through ineptitude, or you deliberately acted in such a way to cover for the Nazis swarming your discord, making sure the incriminating messages would no longer be there when the reports got looked at. You're either incompetent or a sympathiser. [[User:Igotmadenoughtomakeanewaccount|Igotmadenoughtomakeanewaccount]] ([[User talk:Igotmadenoughtomakeanewaccount|talk]]) 05:13, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::::Oh, like I said, 100% incompetent (or maybe ignorant is the better word — never had this problem on any other discord servers I'm on, tbh). {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 05:20, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::To give a wiki sort-of-comparable example, there was a misconduct case [[UDWiki:Administration/Sysop Archives/Aichon/2013-02-21 Misconduct|back in 2013]] that pretty much hinged on, "are sysops obligated to use their powers, and use them promptly, to ban a user if that user violates wiki rules?" The answer was, in fact, a resounding "no". (There's a lot else happening in that case, so have fun in the treasure trove that is the archives!) {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 04:49, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::Oof, hate to be that guy, but I think there's a more appropriate example than that case- in [[UDWiki:Administration/Misconduct/Archive/Vapor/2011#Axe_Hack.2C_Vapor.2C_Karek.2C_Revenant.2C_Spiderzed|this case]] Vapor, unobligated and unprompted, banned a user outright because he committed a case of 'text rape', and chose to permaban them, against all existing policy on the wiki, and all precedent facing the community, with only the sysops to stand in the way of the ban. Does that sound as stupid as it seems? Because I assure you it was. 
::::::In my 11 years on the wiki it's literally the only time it was ever done, unpunished, against strict guidelines, and the sysops unilaterally (and idiotically- case in point, everything happening right now) backed it up 100%, creating the precedent that sysops can ban people for whatever they want, given legal justification of backing the wiki server TOS (which basically allows sysops to override the guidelines as they wish) despite being able to, you know, simply ''warn'' the user and have said TOS violating edits deleted. Like any other sensitive edit. Wouldn't have been a big deal. But the sysop team did the most inane possible move and chose to disregard adherence to  hundreds of cases of established norms, and thats a precedent we're stuck with, unless it's tested.
::::::Again, I think the precedent has always been idiotic and I don't care for the kind of shocking groupthink demanded by butthurt dwellers that somehow think rallying for 48 hours against a 5-hour troll somehow saves humanity from the foreboding plague of Nazism, but here we are.  {{User:DanceDanceRevolution/tcs}} 16:23, 18 August 2018 (UTC)

::::::: posting to note my being triggered by a statement, made by Stelar, that The Malton Globetrotters are anything but exemplary wikizens. smdftb--[[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]] <sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub> '''<span style="color: #ff0000">►</span>[[User:LCpl Mendoza|
<span style="color: #ff0000">ア</span><span style="color: #ee0011">ー</span><span style="color: #dd0022">・ヒ</span><span style="color: #cc0033">ュ</span><span style="color: #bb0044">ー</span><span style="color: #aa0055">ジ</span><span style="color: #990066">・ゲ</span><span style="color: #880077">イ</span><span style="color: #770088">ピ</span><span style="color: #660099">ン</span><span style="color: #5500aa">グ</span><span style="color: #4400bb">・バ</span><span style="color: #3300cc">ジ</span><span style="color: #2200dd">ャ</span><span style="color: #1100ee">イ</span><span style="color: #0000ff">ナ</span>]]<span style="color: #0000ff">◄</span>''' <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: #0000ff; font-size:50%">スナック ストロング</span>]]</sup> <sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup> [[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]][[Image:Mandozersigtag.png]][[Image:555Manbabies.gif‎]] 19:34, 19 August 2018 (UTC)

==My Thoughts (as a Sysop)==
I'm a '''wiki''' sysop. I never signed up to be a Discord admin and have zero interest in being one. I'm only on Discord as a way to be more accessible to people who want to bring ''wiki'' concerns to my attention. That's it. The fact that I was given the "sysop" label on the server was something that I viewed as a courtesy so that people could more easily recognize who I was, but I have neither the time nor the desire to involve myself in Discord, let alone in its policing. I didn't ask for it, and I certainly won't allow myself to be bullied into taking action by people demanding an immediate response to a non-immediate problem that can just as easily be dealt with at a later time. Particularly so when those demands impinge on my real life comings-and-goings.

As for my thoughts as an infrequent Discord user, ''if'' the Discord server is supposed to be "the wiki Discord", then it needs to act like the extension of the community that it's supposed to be. Corn lost the privilege to be a part of this community for very good reasons. As an extension of the community, it makes no sense to allow his presence on the server while still disallowing it here. If he wants back in, we already have a process he is welcome to go through to regain access. Simple as that. Until he goes through it, permabans on the wiki should extend to Discord.

Speaking more generally, I don't think sysops should, by default, be moderators on the Discord server. It's fine to label them as "sysops", but in case people aren't aware, [[UDWiki:Administration/Policy_Discussion/Sysops_are_not_Moderators|sysops are not moderators]], so it makes sense to promote moderators on Discord via a separate process. There may be some overlap with the sysops, but there needn't be. It makes no sense to me that I have full authority to ban people or take other action on Discord despite popping in maybe once a month, while people who are modeling good behavior on a daily basis in there have no ability to take action. {{User:Aichon/Signature}} 16:05, 16 August 2018 (UTC)

A few points of clarification to bad assumptions, misunderstandings, and outright untruths I’m seeing repeated about me in the walls of text above:
#Contrary to the notion that we were ignoring summons, I excused myself from a real life event in response to the VERY first notification I received. I have @everyone notifications disabled (they’re routinely abused), no one ever @Aichon’d me, and no one thought to DM me until much later, so I didn’t receive any notifications prior to the first @sysop, which was apparently hours and hours after Corn had left. 
#I listened patiently for 10 minutes—again, while excusing myself from real life activities—and couldn’t make heads or tails of what was going on, other than that a lot of people were upset and demanding nonspecific action (i.e. a regular day on the Internet). Whatever the situation ''had'' been, it had clearly been over for hours by the time I showed up, meaning that it was not urgent, did not require my immediate attention, and could just as easily be addressed later.
#I explained as much in chat and said that I would be leaving, but that if someone would post a concise explanation on my talk page, I’d be happy to look it over as time allowed and take action then. '''No one did''', so I assumed whatever the situation had been, it had either fizzled or been otherwise resolved.
#The “sysops are not moderators” comment I made above had absolutely nothing to do with why I acted as I did, nor did I ever suggest it did. That whole paragraph is quite clearly about how I think things ''should'' work, but it had no impact on my thinking then. In fact, quite the contrary, despite it not being my responsibility, I’d have been happy to have dealt with this situation ''had anyone actually provided the explanation I asked for.''
#My stance with regards to Corn is well documented on the wiki and stretches back nearly a decade. It speaks for itself. Only people ignorant of the past and foolish enough to give voice to their ignorance would suggest I support Corn’s filth.
As a final note, with me retiring from the wiki and broader community in a few months, this whole episode—which, again, deals with things that were never my responsibility—simply costs more of my time, attention, and concern than I am willing to give it. I was on Discord to be more easily accessible to anyone with wiki concerns. If going above and beyond like that means putting up with this sort of drama, it simply isn’t worth it to me . As such, I decided to move up my retirement a bit, at least with regards to Discord. I left the server and have no intention of returning. My talk page still works fine if anyone needs to reach me. {{User:Aichon/Signature}} 07:04, 19 August 2018 (UTC)

: translation: there is no crossover between {{WIKILAW}} and DICKSCORD LAW. I looked at my smart phone a few times during dinner and dont appreciate how little you appreciate me so im gonna quit my job as a worthless {{WIKILAW}} shitlord slightly faster.--[[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]] <sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub> '''<span style="color: #ff0000">►</span>[[User:LCpl Mendoza|
<span style="color: #ff0000">ア</span><span style="color: #ee0011">ー</span><span style="color: #dd0022">・ヒ</span><span style="color: #cc0033">ュ</span><span style="color: #bb0044">ー</span><span style="color: #aa0055">ジ</span><span style="color: #990066">・ゲ</span><span style="color: #880077">イ</span><span style="color: #770088">ピ</span><span style="color: #660099">ン</span><span style="color: #5500aa">グ</span><span style="color: #4400bb">・バ</span><span style="color: #3300cc">ジ</span><span style="color: #2200dd">ャ</span><span style="color: #1100ee">イ</span><span style="color: #0000ff">ナ</span>]]<span style="color: #0000ff">◄</span>''' <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: #0000ff; font-size:50%">スナック ストロング</span>]]</sup> <sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup> [[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]][[Image:Mandozersigtag.png]][[Image:555Manbabies.gif‎]] 19:29, 19 August 2018 (UTC)
::Nailed it. I should’ve just started with that. {{User:Aichon/Signature}} 21:59, 19 August 2018 (UTC)

::: it certainly would have been more succint --[[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]] <sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub> '''<span style="color: #ff0000">►</span>[[User:LCpl Mendoza|
<span style="color: #ff0000">ア</span><span style="color: #ee0011">ー</span><span style="color: #dd0022">・ヒ</span><span style="color: #cc0033">ュ</span><span style="color: #bb0044">ー</span><span style="color: #aa0055">ジ</span><span style="color: #990066">・ゲ</span><span style="color: #880077">イ</span><span style="color: #770088">ピ</span><span style="color: #660099">ン</span><span style="color: #5500aa">グ</span><span style="color: #4400bb">・バ</span><span style="color: #3300cc">ジ</span><span style="color: #2200dd">ャ</span><span style="color: #1100ee">イ</span><span style="color: #0000ff">ナ</span>]]<span style="color: #0000ff">◄</span>''' <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: #0000ff; font-size:50%">スナック ストロング</span>]]</sup> <sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup> [[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]][[Image:Mandozersigtag.png]][[Image:555Manbabies.gif‎]] 22:05, 19 August 2018 (UTC)
:::: your post is missing something critical though, there's something hidden within your words...gimme a sec to find something suitable to represent it --[[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]] <sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub> '''<span style="color: #ff0000">►</span>[[User:LCpl Mendoza|
<span style="color: #ff0000">ア</span><span style="color: #ee0011">ー</span><span style="color: #dd0022">・ヒ</span><span style="color: #cc0033">ュ</span><span style="color: #bb0044">ー</span><span style="color: #aa0055">ジ</span><span style="color: #990066">・ゲ</span><span style="color: #880077">イ</span><span style="color: #770088">ピ</span><span style="color: #660099">ン</span><span style="color: #5500aa">グ</span><span style="color: #4400bb">・バ</span><span style="color: #3300cc">ジ</span><span style="color: #2200dd">ャ</span><span style="color: #1100ee">イ</span><span style="color: #0000ff">ナ</span>]]<span style="color: #0000ff">◄</span>''' <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: #0000ff; font-size:50%">スナック ストロング</span>]]</sup> <sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup> [[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]][[Image:Mandozersigtag.png]][[Image:555Manbabies.gif‎]] 22:06, 19 August 2018 (UTC)

:::::[[File:Rabloobloobloo.gif]] --[[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]] <sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub> '''<span style="color: #ff0000">►</span>[[User:LCpl Mendoza|
<span style="color: #ff0000">ア</span><span style="color: #ee0011">ー</span><span style="color: #dd0022">・ヒ</span><span style="color: #cc0033">ュ</span><span style="color: #bb0044">ー</span><span style="color: #aa0055">ジ</span><span style="color: #990066">・ゲ</span><span style="color: #880077">イ</span><span style="color: #770088">ピ</span><span style="color: #660099">ン</span><span style="color: #5500aa">グ</span><span style="color: #4400bb">・バ</span><span style="color: #3300cc">ジ</span><span style="color: #2200dd">ャ</span><span style="color: #1100ee">イ</span><span style="color: #0000ff">ナ</span>]]<span style="color: #0000ff">◄</span>''' <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: #0000ff; font-size:50%">スナック ストロング</span>]]</sup> <sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup> [[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]][[Image:Mandozersigtag.png]][[Image:555Manbabies.gif‎]] 22:24, 19 August 2018 (UTC)

==Guy who posted above me is a fucking scrub==

sick post about how banning nazis is effort and totally someone else's job--[[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]] <sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub> '''<span style="color: #ff0000">►</span>[[User:LCpl Mendoza|
<span style="color: #ff0000">ア</span><span style="color: #ee0011">ー</span><span style="color: #dd0022">・ヒ</span><span style="color: #cc0033">ュ</span><span style="color: #bb0044">ー</span><span style="color: #aa0055">ジ</span><span style="color: #990066">・ゲ</span><span style="color: #880077">イ</span><span style="color: #770088">ピ</span><span style="color: #660099">ン</span><span style="color: #5500aa">グ</span><span style="color: #4400bb">・バ</span><span style="color: #3300cc">ジ</span><span style="color: #2200dd">ャ</span><span style="color: #1100ee">イ</span><span style="color: #0000ff">ナ</span>]]<span style="color: #0000ff">◄</span>''' <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: #0000ff; font-size:50%">スナック ストロング</span>]]</sup> <sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup> [[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]][[Image:Mandozersigtag.png]][[Image:555Manbabies.gif‎]] 18:46, 19 August 2018 (UTC)

: also lmao at dude being like "I'm {{WIKILAW}} not discord law, how dare you unappreciative nerds bitch at me about things. I'm gonna retire from my post at {{WIKILAW}} a day earlier cause of this shit. Fuck you."--[[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]] <sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub> '''<span style="color: #ff0000">►</span>[[User:LCpl Mendoza|
<span style="color: #ff0000">ア</span><span style="color: #ee0011">ー</span><span style="color: #dd0022">・ヒ</span><span style="color: #cc0033">ュ</span><span style="color: #bb0044">ー</span><span style="color: #aa0055">ジ</span><span style="color: #990066">・ゲ</span><span style="color: #880077">イ</span><span style="color: #770088">ピ</span><span style="color: #660099">ン</span><span style="color: #5500aa">グ</span><span style="color: #4400bb">・バ</span><span style="color: #3300cc">ジ</span><span style="color: #2200dd">ャ</span><span style="color: #1100ee">イ</span><span style="color: #0000ff">ナ</span>]]<span style="color: #0000ff">◄</span>''' <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: #0000ff; font-size:50%">スナック ストロング</span>]]</sup> <sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup> [[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]][[Image:Mandozersigtag.png]][[Image:555Manbabies.gif‎]] 19:30, 19 August 2018 (UTC)
::Do you need a tissue for your incoherent abloobloo? --'''<span style="font-family:monospace; background-color:#222222">[[User:Spiderzed|<span style="color:Lime"> Spiderzed</span>]][[User talk:Spiderzed|<span style="color:Lime">▋</span>]]</span>''' 20:50, 19 August 2018 (UTC)
:::Hand him a box so he can share with his friends. Soft cushins too. -- [[User:Jack&#39;s Inflamed Sense Of Rejection|King AudioAttack]] ([[User talk:Jack&#39;s Inflamed Sense Of Rejection|talk]]) 21:37, 19 August 2018 (UTC)
::::[[file:GETOUT.gif]]
::::--{{User:Dragonshardz/dragonshardz}} {{Goonsig|Dragonshardz}} 21:45, 19 August 2018 (UTC)

::::: hey i remember spiderzed, that's the dude who was creeping on katthew way back when...fucking lol that you still exist --[[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]] <sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub> '''<span style="color: #ff0000">►</span>[[User:LCpl Mendoza|
<span style="color: #ff0000">ア</span><span style="color: #ee0011">ー</span><span style="color: #dd0022">・ヒ</span><span style="color: #cc0033">ュ</span><span style="color: #bb0044">ー</span><span style="color: #aa0055">ジ</span><span style="color: #990066">・ゲ</span><span style="color: #880077">イ</span><span style="color: #770088">ピ</span><span style="color: #660099">ン</span><span style="color: #5500aa">グ</span><span style="color: #4400bb">・バ</span><span style="color: #3300cc">ジ</span><span style="color: #2200dd">ャ</span><span style="color: #1100ee">イ</span><span style="color: #0000ff">ナ</span>]]<span style="color: #0000ff">◄</span>''' <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: #0000ff; font-size:50%">スナック ストロング</span>]]</sup> <sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sub>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]<sup>[[Image:Flame.gif|6px]]</sup> [[Image:F0b515c3623e9654.jpg|14px]][[Image:Mandozersigtag.png]][[Image:555Manbabies.gif‎]] 21:49, 19 August 2018 (UTC)

==My thoughts/decisions as creator of the discord server==
I did not expect to wake up this morning to see things like "1280+ messages since 5:30pm". I did not expect to be @ed a zillion and a half times. Stelar has already '''disabled @everyone and @here for anyone who isn't a sysop''', which I formally endorse.

I originally intended the discord server to be an extension of the wiki; however, it's not officially affiliated with Urban Dead or the wiki. If Kevan appears, I'll hand it right on over to him, but until then I am '''technically sole dictator''' on the server.

Because Corn is permabanned on the wiki, I've '''banned him from the discord''' and deleted all of his messages. I reserve the right to ban others.

I'm hereby '''deleting the #off-topic channel''', and implementing a policy that the '''wiki discord is for discussions of relevance to the game, wiki and Urban Dead only'''. I'm not gonna go through and delete prior messages that qualify as off-topic (although I might if I have time), but will delete ones henceforth which aren't of relevance to the wiki or game.

I 100% hear what Aichon's saying above. I'm leaving sysops with powers for the moment, since my intention was never for sysops to be moderators, but for them to be readily identifiable (to answer wiki questions etc.), and to be able to assist me in moderating '''if they so choose'''. I'll try to do better being sole confirmed moder-tator.

I've sent a message equivalent to the above on the server as well, and pointed people here if they have further comments. I'll try to check in frequently over the next few days. {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 18:10, 16 August 2018 (UTC)
:I'm fine with you taking the role of moderator on the discord, sounds like a good option, as long as you're happy taking responsibility for stuff like this. 
:However I personally don't believe ban lengths (particularly permabans) should carry over to Discord straight off the bat. There are uses the channel can have in allowing permabanned users asking to be let back onto the wiki via A/DE through it's regular channels, ie. Someone puts the request in on their behalf. The fact that Cornholioo has made an alt to achieve this himself (a precedent from Izumi's A/DE that we are inclined to unfortunately allow) is something I see as a side effect to outright mirroring UDWiki's ban system onto Discord. They are different platforms. {{User:DanceDanceRevolution/tcs}} 22:08, 16 August 2018 (UTC)
::A fair point. But currently, a permabanned user could email a sysop for an appeal, no? (Also, what messages pop up for a permabanned user? Anything at all?)--{{User:A Helpful Little Gnome/Sig}} 00:42, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
::I'd be fine with a user who's permabanned joining the discord for the purpose of finding a sysop or other user to privately message and ask for them to file a permaban de-escalation on their behalf. (This is assuming discord is an easier venue to do so than, say, email.) Corn didn't do this — he joined the discord to chat about Urban Dead <s>(and then about other stuff)</s>, hence the ban. {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 17:52, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
:::Yeah, that's fair enough, and as you said AHLG, email is practically easier too. {{User:DanceDanceRevolution/tcs}} 16:25, 18 August 2018 (UTC)

==fart fart slap slap the rules suck and so does having sysops as sometimes moderators==

Did that get your attention? Good. Let's get into it. Bob's current rules suck. They suck for users, they suck for moderation, they suck for the community. For reference, the rules currently posted in the resources channel are:
<blockquote>1. No off-topic discussion. The former #off-topic channel was deleted for a reason. Off-topic content will be deleted.<br />
2. Repeated off-topic discussion, especially discussion that disrupts the use of the server for on-topic purposes, may lead to the following consequences:<br />
- "timeout", in which the server becomes read-only<br />
- permaban<br />
3. Familiarize yourself with the Discord TOS. If you violate it, you're out and your messages will be reported.<br />
4. All such bans may be handed out by those with the Sysop role at their discretion. However, this server is a dictatorship, so Bob's rule is final. Sysops are also under no obligation to do anything at any time ever if they don't want to.<br />
5. If you would like to contribute comments on these changes, there is an Open Discussion on the wiki here: http://wiki.urbandead.com/index.php/UDWiki:Open_Discussion/Implementation_of_UDWiki_Discord_rules<br />
6. The most fundamental rule: there is no one keeping you here. If you don't like how this server operates, feel free to create your own!<br />
Thanks, and have a great day everybody!</blockquote>

These rules as they exist present a number of issues. I say this as a person who has a part in running a much larger Discord server for r/Runnerhub, not only as a user.

To start, Rule #1 does not define what "off-topic" content is. This is a content rule which is poorly defined and does not lay out enough information to allow moderators to make the quick judgement calls necessary to moderating a real-time chat. This needs to be improved to define off-topic content as dicussion which is not relevant to Urban Dead or UDWiki. Additionally, this is the ideal point to emphasize that discussions should take place in the most appropriate channel.

Rule #2 is a good behavior rule, and lays out the consequences for misbehavior. However, it can be improved by including an escalating set of consequences to be used at the discretion of moderators - EG, deletion of offending messages, short mute lasting a few minutes, a longer mute lasting an hour, a temporary ban, and then a permanent ban. It could also be improved by expanding the scope to cover ANY kind of bad behavior, not just off-topic conversation.

Rule #3 is another behavior rule, and it is an okay one since it reiterates that the Discord ToS apply.

Rule #4 is bad. Having people with the power to levy consequences for misbehavior, without expecting them to take an active role in doing so, is bad for a community. There is a reason that other Discord servers and social platforms like Reddit have moderators which take an active role, in addition to admins. The structure of the Discord server should include dedicated moderators - no more than necessary to have reasonable timezone coverage - and [[UDWiki:Administration/Policy_Discussion/Sysops_are_not_Moderators|sysops should not be the default choice as moderation staff.]] Of the sysops, one has demonstrated a clear lack of desire to perform as a Discord moderator, and in my opinon has shown a measure of bias which does not lead me to believe they can be entrusted with the rights and responsibilities of a moderator.

That said, sysops should not be barred from being Discord moderators, rather, being a moderator on Discord should be a voluntary duty taken up by trusted members of the community ''who are willing to be held accountable to enforcing the code of conduct on the Discord server.'' "Wiki Sysop" should be a vanity role - a role with no powers above that of a standard user - distinct from the role of "Moderator". Let the sysops who so desire to moderate Discord, let those who do not wish to - or cannot be trusted to do so in a just manner - be decoupled from the privileges thereof.

Rule #5 is a call for feedback, and is mostly fine.

Rule #6 needs to go away. Openly stating that sentiment - "if you don't like it, there's the door" is not necessary and is hostile to new members of the community. The Discord server being opt-in and unofficially official already implies this, anyway.

So now that I've covered the problems I see, what next? Firstly, let's draw up some better rules. Rather than numbering them, I'll break them into two broad policies: Content and Behavior.

<blockquote>
'''CONTENT POLICY'''

Discussion on this server must be relevant to the context of Urban Dead or UDWiki. Discussion which is not is deemed off-topic, and may be summarily deleted at Staff discretion.

Discussions around actions taking place within Urban Dead belong in the #in-game channel. Similarly, discussions relevant to UDWiki belong in #udwiki.

Sexism, harassment, incitation to real-life violence, and other content which does not abide by the Discord ToS is not welcome.

'''BEHAVIOR POLICY'''

Patterns of behavior which disrupt the purpose of the server will result in an escalating set of consequences at the discretion of server staff. These consequences are:<br />
1. Deletion of messages coupled with direction to the appropriate channel.<br />
2. A mute lasting no less than ten minutes.<br />
3. A mute lasting no less than one hour.<br />
4. A ban lasting no less than 24 hours.<br />
5. A permanent ban.<br />

Behavior not covered here which violates the Discord ToS is not allowed, and will result in your removal from the server.</blockquote>

Secondly, post these rules in a specific, dedicated channel named #rules, to which the Discord invite is linked. No in #resources, in #rules. This works for other Discord servers and for good reason; it surfaces the server policies in a way which cannot be missed and which provides no excuse for ignorance.

Thirdly, decouple the Sysop rule from the various moderation powers it currently has, and designate trusted users to perform as moderation staff when Bob is not around. Most importantly, ''these users must be expected to discharge the responsibility of filling in for Bob or face removal.'' One man cannot effectively moderate a real-time chat that's active 24/7/365, thus, it's in the best interests to delegate that as needed to people who will do their job instead excusing their refusal to do so by pleading ignorance, lack of time, etc.

Lastly, expecting that malefactors will stop doing a thing because they've been lightly tsked at is silly, unrealistic, ineffective, and ultimately a detriment to the community. Bullies don't go away because they're ignored; trolls don't go away if they're told they're being off-topic. Rules need to be actively enforced by moderators who are willing and able to do so. It should not take multiple hours of discussion to convince moderators that yes, the guy who openly advocates for white supremacy really should be banned. Users should not have to endure being labeled The Problem when they try to bring a problem to the attention of those who can do something about it.

I hope you enjoyed the ride. I sure did. If this was too much to read, here's a TL;DR: The current rules suck. I suggested better ones, at least as a baseline. If sysops are not moderators, then they should not have the power to moderate. There should be moderators who actively moderate. --{{User:Dragonshardz/dragonshardz}} {{Goonsig|Dragonshardz}} 01:29, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
::Endorsing this whole heartedly, and I think it would forestall any futher incidents like today's explosion. [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 01:35, 31 August 2018 (UTC)

:Thank you so much for the very constructive criticism!
:The rules I posted I slapped together very quickly at user request. I've edited rule #1 per your request — thanks!
:I'm not editing rule #2 to implement specific escalation because I'm '''not willing''' to track, or have another track, where anyone is on the escalation scale. Users should behave as though full deletion of all comments (except where needed to report to Discord) and permaban are the automatic options; lower options are at my discretion, and I've edited the rule as such.
:Rule #4 is not being changed; see the vast amount of discussion on this topic above. Think of me like a janitor ("not a nanny", to quote the illustrious Aichon) and the rest of the sops as a volunteer fire department, to come in in emergencies and quash things until I appear. (This is also in response to your tl;dr.)
:Rule #6 was added at user request. I've removed it, but it's still true, and I will remind users of it as it comes up.
:The rules are remaining in #resources, as they're a resource, and there's no way I'm creating another channel on the server to hold a single message. It was moved into the #resources channel from being just a pinned message in #welcome as pinned messages are less accessible to mobile users. I've changed the message at the top of #welcome to direct users to #resources.
:As for "One man cannot effectively moderate a real-time chat that's active 24/7/365", this is true if you want real-time moderation. The best thing to do is to tag me, then do not feed any trolls or spammers and just wait it out. If you'd like a server that has an extensive moderation team, '''make one'''.
:By the way, it didn't "take multiple hours of discussion to convince moderators that yes, the guy who openly advocates for white supremacy really should be banned." It took one minute of a user PMing me and me then coming online. I didn't ''read'' the multiple hours of discussion — it did ''nothing'' but antagonize me and the other sysops. If I labeled it "a problem", I never meant such and I apologize — I meant to label it "completely irrelevant to my life".
:Thanks again for your comments, they were very helpful! I've copy-pasted the current revised rules below so others can comment further. {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 01:53, 31 August 2018 (UTC)

{{quote|Bob Moncrief|1. No off-topic discussion, aka discussion not of relevance to the game (which should largely be in #in-game ) or wiki (ditto #udwiki ). The former #off-topic channel was deleted for a reason. Off-topic content will be deleted.<br/>
2. Repeated off-topic discussion, especially discussion that disrupts the use of the server for on-topic purposes, may lead to the following consequences:<br/>
- "timeout", in which the server becomes read-only for that user<br/>
- permaban<br/>
There is no specific scale of escalations. Users should assume that violations will lead to permaban every time; timeouts and temporary bans are at my discression.<br/>
3. Familiarize yourself with the Discord TOS. If you violate it, you're out and your messages will be reported.<br/>
4. All such bans may be handed out by those with the Sysop role at their discretion. However, this server is a dictatorship, so Bob's rule is final. Sysops are also under no obligation to do anything at any time ever if they don't want to.<br/>
5. If you would like to contribute comments on these changes, there is an Open Discussion on the wiki here: ''link to this page trimmed for length''.<br/>
One more guideline: Remember, this is a discord server for an obscure zombie game. It isn't life-or-death — log out for a minute if you need.}}

:::It seems at this point the front page should be changed from "Join the UDWiki Discord Server" to "Join Bob's Personal UD Discord Server," because I guarantee 95% of the people who joined assumed it was the former. Saying "Go make your own" is a bit facile when the userbase is *there* and the server has effectively been imprinted with the "official affiliation" stamp for ages, despite the protestations to the contrary. People *have* tried - spoilers, no-one came. I don't think it's that outrageous that people would want to see what is, for all intents and purposes, the major UD Community Discord server better run. [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 02:00, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
::::Hadn't realized it was still linked from Community Projects! Removed. {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 02:06, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::Guess that's one way to settle that. [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 02:15, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
	
::I was referring more specifically to stelar, who has and did label people bringing issues to her attention and then ''expecting her to do something about them'' as a larger problem than what was being brought to her attention. As for making my own server with active moderation teams, I ''have''. Multiple times, and all of them are quite healthy because of those active moderation teams. I also submit that, again, in a healthy community, ''PMing the owner of the server should not be necessary in order to resolve a problem''. There should be people who are ''actively'' involved in maintaining the health of the community. Proactive > reactive in damn near every situation. Telling members of the community to cede the floor to trolls, spammers, or other malefactors is not good for the long-term health of the community. --{{User:Dragonshardz/dragonshardz}} {{Goonsig|Dragonshardz}} 02:19, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
:::Ok! If I find the existence of the server I created to be detrimental to the health of the overall UD community, I would delete the server. We're nowhere close to that yet. {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 02:43, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
::::"The community" I was referring to is the community made up of the users of the UDWiki Discord. Having moderators who don't moderate is bad, making users cede their communal space to trolls is bad. I've given you advice on how to ensure malefactors get the quick boot they deserve, but also make it so the hours of discussion that only serve to "antagonize" you never have the chance to happen. Responsible, proactive moderation solves more than one problem, which is why I suggest it so vehemently. --{{User:Dragonshardz/dragonshardz}} {{Goonsig|Dragonshardz}} 03:31, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
:::I labelled people? As what? {{User:Stelar/sig}} 02:48, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
::::You were calling the people bringing their concerns to you about the actual violent individual who's publicly threatened to rape and kill people as the "problem" and seemed oblivious to why said person shouldn't be a part of our community. Frankly stelar, if you feel it's a burden to be a moderator on the Discord or don't wish to actually moderate the Discord channel, then you shouldn't have moderator powers there. What benefit is there in sending reports to you if you don't act on them? Moderators need to be responsive; not dismissive. [[User:JAZED|JAZED]] ([[User talk:JAZED|talk]]) 03:14, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::I've seen this accusation against stelar several times and have yet to see any evidence of it. Where did this happen? {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 03:27, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::Most recently, on Discord itself: https://i.imgur.com/Lvm1deC.png --{{User:Dragonshardz/dragonshardz}} {{Goonsig|Dragonshardz}} 03:35, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::::Her tone was somewhat impatient, but she wasn't wrong that others were prolonging the discussion (to the tune of 2,000 messages after Corn logged off), people should have stopped feeding the troll, or that none of the discussion needed to happen in the discord (other than an @Bob ping or so, of course). She didn't label anybody a (or the) problem, and has expressed to me personally full understanding of why Corn got banned. {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 03:42, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::::"Don't feed the troll" only works when there's someone actively around to enforce the policy. Specific discussions not happening only works when someone is actively around the ''enforce the policy''. Do you see where I'm going with this? '''Proactive moderation is the best and most effective way to nip events like this in the bud.''' Continuing to stick your head in the sand only ensures that these kinds of issues will continue, regardless of who is involved. --{{User:Dragonshardz/dragonshardz}} {{Goonsig|Dragonshardz}} 03:47, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::::I also [https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/484930395951988747/484930835003342863/Screenshot_20180830-233838_Discord.jpg submit] [https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/484930395951988747/484930861716865024/Screenshot_20180830-233847_Discord.jpg additional] [https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/484930395951988747/484930887641726976/Screenshot_20180830-233855_Discord.jpg proof] [https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/484930395951988747/484930908248473600/Screenshot_20180830-233908_Discord.jpg that] [https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/484930395951988747/484930928360292352/Screenshot_20180830-233917_Discord.jpg stelar] [https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/484930395951988747/484930949352783872/Screenshot_20180830-233924_Discord.jpg views] [https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/484930395951988747/484930968512102401/Screenshot_20180830-233933_Discord.jpg "the goons"] as [https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/484930395951988747/484930993200037889/Screenshot_20180830-233938_Discord.jpg more of a problem than the literal Nazis and various sympathizers]. --{{User:Dragonshardz/dragonshardz}} {{Goonsig|Dragonshardz}} 03:51, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::::::Where was the permission I gave for you to use a private conversation like that? {{User:Stelar/sig}} 03:58, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::::::Thank you so much, Dragonshardz, for those screenshots! Stelar responded with extreme maturity, an open ear, and grace and poise to someone who was dramatically antagonizing her. Be glad this was in private message and Stelar didn't bring it to me directly, or I would have certainly banned Viva Miriya from the discord server for harassment. {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 03:59, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::::::Any time there's a Goon involved in an argument, it's safe to say Stelar finds a way to make our involvement the real problem, not the actual person. There's a reason people feel antagonistic towards her, this isn't new. When the "You goons are the real problem" is public, and the "Yes, maybe actual Nazis are bad" is private, what do you expect? [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 04:10, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::::::I've only seen a very small set of people "feel antagonistic towards her", all of them members of a couple specific in-game groups. It's not a sentiment shared widely across the wiki or UD community, as far as anyone has shown me. {{User:Bob Moncrief/Sig}} 04:18, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::::::Given that she only appears to have a personal vendetta against one particular group, it's not suprising that group returns the favor. I never claimed it was a mass movement. [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 04:20, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::::::Maybe there is a reason that small set of people feel she is unfairly biased. Maybe the part where she's admitted more than once that she views ''us'' as the problem, since we persist in ''talking about issues that are not resolved'' instead of ceding the floor to Proud Boys, Nazis, and Nazi sympathizers. --{{User:Dragonshardz/dragonshardz}} {{Goonsig|Dragonshardz}} 04:21, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
:::::::::Leave it to you both to determine goons are the problem, and not the pants-on-head attitudes you both so eloquently display. --{{User:Dragonshardz/dragonshardz}} {{Goonsig|Dragonshardz}} 04:12, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::::::Fuck, I'd be hostile too if the person so benevolently endowed with moderation powers failed do something about the Proud Boy threatening me with physical harm. Thank god at least one person had the sense to do what needed to be done. [[User:Sniper4625|Sniper4625]] [[Image:Globetrotters_Icon.png|14px|The Malton Globetrotters]]#4625 - {{Goonsig|Sniper4625}} <sup>[[The Malton Globetrotters|<span style="color: Red">TMG</span>]]</sup> 04:14, 31 August 2018 (UTC)
::::::::::"extreme maturity, an open ear, and grace and poise"? She is dismissive and condescending. Why are goons the problem, but the person who thinks half my family getting gassed would own is not? People are upset because we want to play this game without fuckheads yupping about great Nazism is. [[User:JAZED|JAZED]] ([[User talk:JAZED|talk]]) 04:22, 31 August 2018 (UTC)