User talk:Jack Brandenburg
Hi
just thought I'd drop you a line about your last suggestion. It seems I wrongfully thought it was overpowered. I did the math and it's always inferior to claws after all (since claws has 50% to hit at lvl 2, and 1.5 damage/AP when maxed, plus tangling grasp).
Now I'd still have issues with that suggestion, namely, 75% to hit seems a bit silly high even if the average damage is low. I'm still under the assumption that zombies are supposed to be a bit clumsy with weapons.
Additionnaly, some of us dislike the idea of zombies becoming more like humans.
All in all, it wasn't such a bad suggestion, just one I wasn't particularily fond of. Don't mind the spam votes, some people go a little crazy with them.
I hope this has been useful feedback. --McArrowni 01:14, 22 April 2006 (BST)
User: BuncyTheFrog
Note: This was (meant) to be posted right after you withdrew your first suggestion yesterday, before you re-submitted it.
I was so proud of my vote,
for it all was good rhyme.
'Till I saw that I didn't
quite post it in time.
So here my vote is, with maybe a hint,
of things to do when your suggestion you print.
- Kill - A multi suggestion is this you've put down, but the last part brings me a big frown. "Don't mess with AP" is what people say, and I agree that this won't pass today. A 60 'cent chance to hit with a punch, may make it easy to kill in a crunch. I do not know how the knife will go down, as gripping belongs in zombie town. Well, that is all, I've no more to say. I'll check on this more a day from today. BuncyTheFrog Talk GBP 07:28, 22 April 2006 (BST)
Double Stats
Hi. I know you voted kill initally for the "Double Stats" suggestion due to experience concerns, but if you look at the talk page for it, it has been addressed. I don't think Kevan would allow it to be a problem anyways. Right now, the votes for this suggestion are 20 Keep and 11 Kill. Considering what I just told you, if you could help me get my suggestion into Peer Reviewed, that would be great. You don't even need to vote "Keep". If you just removed your kill vote, that would be enough. I'd really appriciate it. Thank you. --Rozozag 19:00, 20 May 2006 (BST)
