Talk:Undecided Suggestions
When a suggestion comes here, does it simply die or is it re-submitted later, or...? I am seeking to understand the actual function of this page and if it is basically idea limbo. -- Amazing 06:41, 23 Nov 2005 (GMT)
- I highly recommend that someone take the Undecided Suggestions and revise them and re-submit them. Anyone can do it. --Squashua 20:39, 30 Nov 2005 (GMT)
- Yeah, I think notes for undecided suggestions should be a little more detailed than those for rejected, so that people can change and resubmit.--Milo 20:48, 30 Nov 2005 (GMT)
- Should we remove suggestions from here that have the same idea/basis/goals if it's in the peer reviewed suggestions page? or is that up to the descression of the author of the new suggestion. - Jedaz 12:44, 12 Dec 2005 (GMT)
- I'd say remove or at least add a note on it with a link to the similar, reviewed, suggestion. Note any major differences. --Squashua 14:44, 12 Dec 2005 (GMT)
- Should we remove suggestions from here that have the same idea/basis/goals if it's in the peer reviewed suggestions page? or is that up to the descression of the author of the new suggestion. - Jedaz 12:44, 12 Dec 2005 (GMT)
- Yeah, I think notes for undecided suggestions should be a little more detailed than those for rejected, so that people can change and resubmit.--Milo 20:48, 30 Nov 2005 (GMT)
test
just testing the format and such... but with a topic of "speach" in game.... its quite obsurd to make it cost 1 full action point... I know its to prevent noobs from coming in and spamming up the rooms, but maybe a seperate chat box (shouldnt be too difficult with java)and if things get out of hand spamming, have a "ignore player" feature? Most games "talking" is a "free action" because expecially when a player is new, they have questions.. like "wheres the nearest necro tech building?" the 50ap a day would be much more barable if we could talk for free, I tend to not say a thing, wich really hurts in game playing, because I have already calculated it would take X ap to get where iam going to be safe for the night. Just a suggestion/question feel free to discuss this, or if you wish to, delete. ~Yeldarb.
Guidelines for Resubmission
I think there needs to be a note added to any resubmitted suggestion from this page that this was originally undecided. Perhaps:
This suggestion was originally Undecided.
Originally Suggested - Date
Changes since original submission - Details of changes made.
As an addendum to the suggestion when posted.
Archived Suggestions
In a bid to make this page more friendly for editors (such as me) I have split up the suggestions for their respective months. - Jedaz 08:55, 13 May 2006 (BST)
- Also as a note to other people adding the suggestions to the page, since there is just a small amount of undecided we are not going to alredy have the headings for the days as with the peer rejected suggestions. When you add a suggestions place it under it's respective day or if it is not there create the heading for it - Jedaz 08:58, 13 May 2006 (BST)
