UDWiki:Administration/Arbitration/Xeeron vs Ruining
|
Administration Services — Protection. This page has been protected against editing. See the archive of recent actions or the Protections log. |
Ruining vs Xeeron
Someone please clarify this issue, before we both get stuck in a long revert war. The site in question is Siege of Ackland Mall where my edit has been reverted 4 times so far by User:Ruining. Check also this for the source of the quote and my talk page for some rather fruitless discussion. --Xeeron 16:29, 27 Jan 2006 (GMT)
Looking at the links Ruining appears to be in the wrong as he is vandalising pages and insulting you for no valid reason, however, I will wait until Ruining posts his side of the story before making a desicion.--The General 11:23, 29 Jan 2006 (GMT)
I keep rolling it back because Barco, if you'd ask him yourself and as he's told me, meant he'd like help from the game and the random number generator, as in, "I'd love to not get shafted by the random number generator." Instead, Xeeron, without talking to Barco, started posting as if Barco had gone all nancy boy, crying for help at Ackland. Barco is "disgusted with the entire issue." He knows that I'm leading the Ackland campaign and would not countermand me or ask for assistance without my go-ahead. The same applies when he or Nav have charge of the horde since we rotate control; the other two leaders step back and offer support and advice only. Barco hopes that such misrepresentation causes people to "choke on their own bile." Xeeron, in a humanist smear campaign, continues to misquote Barco without so much as footnoting to the original context or speaking to Barco. As Pwotters does not go about posting snippets of humans whining whenever they're getting consumed, we're outraged by the situaton. However, we understand that people become overzelous at times; we've been known for it ourselves. Therefore, we ask that Xeeron not be banned, as the court ought generally do to griefers. To the best of my knowledge, this is the first time that Xeeron has been in trouble for such malicious actions. We Pwotters feel that justice would best be served with a stern warning to Xeeron to not attempt to impersonate or explain the words of others in the others' stead.
Thank you. -- Ruining 12:23, 29 Jan 2006 (EST)
Looking at all the evidence it appears that Xeeron was quoting out of context and you were right to revert it. The descion is that Xeeron should cease posting his edit on the page. However, it looks like an honest mistake and no further action should be taken as long as Xeeron does not re-post his edit.--The General 20:39, 29 Jan 2006 (GMT)
Well if with this (full, noting removed, he only posted this and nothing else) quote "We could use some help, actually. The server is curiously slow and the barricades are curiously fast at being repaired. Barcoded 12:27, 25 Jan 2006 (GMT)" he was requesting a better random number generator and not more zombie players, my apologies to Barcoded. Further apologies if anyone did mistake the quoted quote as his statement instead of a quote. You don't have to worry about any further missunderstandings since I will stick to wikis where people are less likely to missunderstand me and where I won't be cussed at for arguing my point. --Xeeron 00:08, 1 Feb 2006 (GMT)
In other words your going to leave just because you lost an arbitration descion? I agree that Ruining's comments were unwarrented but you cannot expect a descsion based on that. On the other hand Barcoded's edits are a completely different matter and if this continues the descision will change as I believe that edits like that void a users right to post or have fair descisions made.--The General 19:23, 4 Feb 2006 (GMT)
