User talk:Revenant/Sandbox/PageFoundry/Devolution of power
+1
Go on?--User:Sexualharrison02:42, 8 June 2011 (bst)
Powers
I assume that with Kevan's powers you mean stuff like editing actual wiki software? Could be helpful if this could be extended to crats, maybe sysops, certainly not normal users considering the damage that can be done. As for sysops powers, maybe giving regular users the ability to move but that would be it. The other exclusive powers like deletion and banning would be open to abuse waaayyy too much.
As for special rights, like being able to vote on A/VB and A/M cases, again no because most cases would devolve into meatpuppet popularity fuckfests. Power needs to be restricted if you want to keep any kind of order on an open public place like this, especially teh web. -- 
Thadeous Oakley Talk 18:59, 9 June 2011 (BST)
- Well on the note of deletion if you could limit it their own user-space then that might be ok. Crit 7 allow sysops to speedy delete pages only the author has edited, and most often user pages only the author(user) has made edits to and it is their user page anywho. Then crit 8 allows deletion of the user subpages so that encompasses a persons user-space. (I hope I interpreted that correctly) Although uploaded images need to still go through the proper channels because of the possibility of breaking links and those ugly boxes appearing everywhere and maybe signatures as well for a similar reason. Then if normal wiki users are granted the deletion power within their own user-space then they could also have the ability to move pages within their own user-space. In my mind that seems reasonable and mostly harmless to the general wiki, need be any deletions can be restored can they not? 19:27, 9 June 2011 (BST)
- I tend to agree but unfortunately it is all or nothing. I don't believe there is functionality in the wiki software to allow users to delete only pages in their own userspace. ~
20:00, 9 June 2011 (UTC)
- Not even with a user-group? Well in that case I agree with thad the ability to delete and move pages needs to be reserved for sysops if it effects anything other than the person's own user-space. However, letting crats do minor software upgrades seems reasonable, things like adding extensions or updating them. It'd take some of the imposed workload off of Kevan if he's willing to share the power. 20:07, 9 June 2011 (BST)
- I tend to agree but unfortunately it is all or nothing. I don't believe there is functionality in the wiki software to allow users to delete only pages in their own userspace. ~
